德尔菲共识达成:制定快速综述方法选择决策工具(STARR)
本研究于2018年5月至7月开展两轮改良在线德尔菲调查,邀请国际快速综述专家对19项预设条目进行重要性排序,预设共识定义为至少70%同意。首轮30名来自10个国家的专家参与即对所有条目达成共识,并新增1项质量评估条目;第二轮24名专家参与,全部20项条目均达成共识,覆盖与委托方互动、证据范围界定与检索、数据提取与合成方法及报告。
要点
- 两轮德尔菲调查达成国际共识,用于制定快速综述方法选择决策工具(STARR)。
- 首轮30名来自10个国家的专家参与,对所有19项预设条目达成共识。
- 第二轮24名专家参与,新增质量评估条目后全部20项条目均达成共识。
核心结论
- 国际专家达成共识,将制定快速综述方法选择(STARR)决策工具,以帮助规划快速综述并改善综述团队与委托方之间的共同理解。
研究设计与样本
- 采用两轮改良在线德尔菲调查,于2018年5月至7月开展,参与者为国际快速综述专家。
- 参与者对预设的19项条目的重要性进行排序,预设共识定义为每个条目至少70%同意。
- 首轮有来自10个国家的30名专家参与,第二轮有24名专家参与。
主要发现
- 首轮调查中所有19项预设条目均达成共识。
- 受访者建议新增1项关于质量评估的条目,并建议修改措辞以提高工具的清晰度和理解度。
- 第二轮调查中受访者表示重要性高,全部20项条目均达成共识。
- 这些条目涉及与委托方互动、证据基础的范围界定与检索、数据提取与合成方法以及快速综述方法的报告。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: There are many rapid review methods; however, there is little pragmatic guidance on which methods to select. This study aimed to reach consensus among international rapid review experts outlining areas to consider when selecting approaches for rapid reviews. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A two-round modified online Delphi survey was conducted between May and July 2018. Participants were asked to rank the importance of a predefined list of 19 items. A consensus definition of at least 70% agreement for each item was decided a priori. RESULTS: Thirty experts from ten countries participated in round 1 and 24 in round 2. During round 1, consensus was reached on all items. One additional item on quality assessment was suggested by respondents and comments suggested wording changes to improve clarity and understanding of the tool. Respondents in the second round indicated a high level of importance and all 20 items achieved consensus. These items addressed interaction with commissioners, scoping and searching the evidence-base, data extraction and synthesis methods, and reporting of rapid review methods. CONCLUSION: International consensus was reached to produce the SelecTing Approaches for Rapid Reviews (STARR) decision tool for planning rapid reviews and will lead to improved shared understanding between review teams and review commissioners.
引用
- Pandor A, Kaltenthaler E, Martyn-St James M, et al. Delphi consensus reached to produce a decision tool for SelecTing Approaches for Rapid Reviews (STARR). J Clin Epidemiol. 2019. PMID: 31185276. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2019.06.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。