一项系统调查识别出36条评估随机试验或Meta分析中效应修饰主张的标准
该研究系统检索MEDLINE、Embase和WorldCat至2018年3月,纳入150篇提供效应修饰可信度评估指导的文献,提取出36条标准及相关理由。常见标准包括交互作用检验显著(n=54)、先验假设(n=49)、提供因果解释(n=47)等。专家对某些标准 suitability 存在分歧,如分层随机化的附加价值与生物学理由的可信度。
要点
- 系统调查识别出36条评估效应修饰主张可信度的标准。
- 常见标准包括交互作用检验显著(n=54)和先验假设(n=49)。
- 专家对分层随机化附加价值等标准存在分歧。
核心结论
- 方法学家已投入大量智力提供对明显效应修饰进行批判性评估的标准,调查凸显了流行标准、专家共识与分歧以及需要更多工作的领域,包括在实践中检验这些标准。
研究设计与样本
- 系统调查方法学文献,检索MEDLINE、Embase和WorldCat至2018年3月,由两名研究者独立筛选并提取标准与理由,通过讨论达成共识,并迭代完善分类体系。
主要发现
- 共识别150篇符合条件的出版物,提供36条标准及相关理由。
- 常见标准包括交互作用检验显著(n=54)、先验假设(n=49)、提供因果解释(n=47)、考虑多重性(n=45)、检验少量效应修饰因子(n=38)和分析细节预设(n=39)。
- 某些标准有多个理由,部分标准通过共同理由相关联。
- 专家对某些标准的适宜性存在分歧,例如分层随机化的附加价值和生物学理由的可信度。
关键数值与推荐
- 交互作用检验显著(n=54)、先验假设(n=49)、提供因果解释(n=47)、考虑多重性(n=45)、检验少量效应修饰因子(n=38)、分析细节预设(n=39)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The objective of the study was to systematically survey the methodological literature and collect suggested criteria for assessing the credibility of effect modification and associated rationales. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We searched MEDLINE, Embase, and WorldCat up to March 2018 for publications providing guidance for assessing the credibility of effect modification identified in randomized trials or meta-analyses. Teams of two investigators independently identified eligible publications and extracted credibility criteria and authors' rationale, reaching consensus through discussion. We created a taxonomy of criteria that we iteratively refined during data abstraction. RESULTS: We identified 150 eligible publications that provided 36 criteria and associated rationales. Frequent criteria included significant test for interaction (n = 54), a priori hypothesis (n = 49), providing a causal explanation (n = 47), accounting for multiplicity (n = 45), testing a small number of effect modifiers (n = 38), and prespecification of analytic details (n = 39). For some criteria, we found more than one rationale; some criteria were connected through a common rationale. For some criteria, experts disagreed regarding their suitability (e.g., added value of stratified randomization; trustworthiness of biologic rationales). CONCLUSION: Methodologists have expended substantial intellectual energy providing criteria for critical appraisal of apparent effect modification. Our survey highlights popular criteria, expert agreement and disagreement, and where more work is needed, including testing criteria in practice.
引用
- Schandelmaier S, Chang Y, Devasenapathy N, et al. A systematic survey identified 36 criteria for assessing effect modification claims in randomized trials or meta-analyses. J Clin Epidemiol. 2019. PMID: 31132471. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2019.05.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。