留意差距?平台试验作为工作环境。
该文基于伦敦大学学院试验团队在STAMPEDE和FOCUS4等平台试验中的管理经验,并结合一项小型定性研究,探讨平台试验给研究人员带来的工作环境挑战。研究识别出高工作负荷、显著压力及对职业选择的影响,并指出初期对所需工作量和固有挑战估计不足,强调需关注试验资源需求及对研究人员的关怀。
要点
- 平台试验的工作环境以复杂性、规模和更高期望为特征,对研究人员造成高工作负荷和显著压力。
- 初期对平台试验所需工作量和固有挑战估计不足,影响个人职业选择及团队关系。
- 需增强对平台试验给整个团队带来挑战的认识,并影响领导者和资助者的预算考虑与交付过程。
核心结论
- 需要增强对平台试验给整个团队带来的挑战的认识,这种考虑必须影响领导者和资助者在初始预算和整个交付过程中的决策。
研究设计与样本
- 基于伦敦大学学院试验团队在STAMPEDE和FOCUS4等平台试验中的管理经验总结,并结合一项小型定性研究,检查研究人员个人体验。
主要发现
- 研究报告了高工作负荷,可能给个人带来显著压力并影响职业选择。
- 研究认为初期低估了所需工作量及固有且大多未预期的挑战。
- 工作环境以复杂性、规模和更高期望为特征,对职业发展极具吸引力并产生高忠诚度和承诺。
- 观察到内在回报与重叠任务的持续需求之间的权衡,以及关键角色性质变化对同事关系的挑战。
- 分子分层实际上将患者作为具体个体带入试验办公室,尽管已匿名化,仍欠其检测结果和治疗决策。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Trials have become bigger and more complicated due to the complexity introduced by biomarker stratification, and the advent of multi-arm multi-stage trials, and umbrella and basket platform designs. The trials unit at University College London has been at the forefront of this work, with ground-breaking trials such as STAMPEDE and FOCUS4. The trial management and data management teams on these trials have summarised the operational challenges, to enable the broader clinical trials community to learn from their experiences. In a small-scale qualitative study, we examined the personal experience of individual researchers working on these trials. COMMENTARY: We found reports of high workloads, with potentially significant stress for individuals and with an impact on their career choices. We conclude that there was an initial underestimation of the work required and of the inherent, largely unanticipated, challenges. We discuss the importance of fully understanding these trials' resource requirements, both for those writing grant applications and critically, for those with responsibility for deciding on funding. The working environment was characterised by three features: complexity, scale and heightened expectations. These features are highly attractive for professional development and engender high levels of loyalty and commitment. We observed a trade-off between these intrinsic rewards and the continuous demands of overlapping tasks, balancing a mix of routine and high-profile work, and the changing nature of pivotal roles. Such demands present challenges for colleague relationships, by enhancing the potential for competition and by disrupting the natural opportunities to pause, review and celebrate team achievements. In addition, molecular stratification in effect brings the patient into the trial office, as a specific individual, despite anonymisation, who is owed test results and a treatment decision. We discuss these observations with a view to interconnecting the need for compassion for patients with caring for the researchers engaged in the research ecosystem who are aiming to produce much hoped-for advances in medical science. CONCLUSIONS: There is a need for increased awareness of the challenge these studies place on those throughout the team delivering the study. Such considerations must influence leaders and funders, both in their initial budget considerations and throughout delivery.
引用
- Morrell L, Hordern J, Brown L, et al. Mind the gap? The platform trial as a working environment. Trials. 2019. PMID: 31138284. doi:10.1186/s13063-019-3377-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。