使知识使用者参与老年科医生主导照护模式比较效果系统评价是可行的:基于患者参与评估工具的横断面调查
该研究在开展老年科医生主导照护模式比较效果的系统评价时,采用整合知识转化方法,邀请患者、照护者、老年科医生和政策制定者参与三项活动,并用患者参与评估工具评估感知参与程度。15名知识使用者完成评估,各活动中位参与评分为6.00-6.50,面对面会议在信任、合法性、公平性和能力方面的评分高于线上活动。结论认为知识使用者可有意义地参与系统评价过程,且面对面活动的感知参与度更高。
要点
- 15名知识使用者完成患者参与评估工具,各活动中位参与评分为6.00-6.50,提示感知到参与。
- 面对面会议在信任(P=0.005)、合法性(P=0.003)、公平性(P=0.013)和能力(P=0.035)上的评分高于线上活动。
- 知识使用者可有意义地参与系统评价过程,面对面活动的感知参与度高于线上活动。
核心结论
- 知识使用者可有意义地参与系统评价过程,其感知参与度在面对面活动中高于线上活动。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面调查,知识使用者包括来自加拿大三个省的患者、照护者、老年科医生和政策制定者。
- 活动包括改良德尔菲法选择结局、横断面调查选择结局测量工具、面对面会议讨论系统评价结果。
- 在第二和第三项活动后使用患者参与评估工具评估参与程度,采用7点李克特量表从「完全没有」到「非常大程度」评分。
主要发现
- 共15名知识使用者完成患者参与评估工具:8名老年科医生、4名政策制定者、2名患者和1名照护者。
- 所有活动的中位参与评分范围为6.00-6.50,提示知识使用者感到被参与。
- 面对面会议在信任(P=0.005)、合法性(P=0.003)、公平性(P=0.013)和能力(P=0.035)方面的元标准评分高于线上活动。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A systematic review (SR) was conducted to evaluate the comparative effectiveness of geriatrician-led models of care, and an integrated knowledge translation (iKT) approach facilitated SR relevance. Activities to engage knowledge users (KUs) in the SR were evaluated for perceived level of engagement. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: KUs included patients, caregivers, geriatricians, and policymakers from three Canadian provinces. Activities included 1) modified Delphi to select outcomes; 2) cross-sectional survey to select outcome measures, and 3) in-person meeting to discuss SR findings. KU engagement was assessed using the Patient Engagement Evaluation Tool (PEET) after the second and third activities. KUs rated the extent of successful engagement using a 7-point Likert scale ranging from "no extent" to "very large extent." RESULTS: In total, 15 KUs completed the PEET: eight geriatricians, four policymakers, two patients, and one caregiver. Median engagement scores across all activities (median range: 6.00-6.50) indicated that KUs felt engaged. Differences were observed for activity type; perceived engagement at in-person meeting resulted in higher meta-criteria scores for trust (P = 0.005), legitimacy (P = 0.003), fairness (P = 0.013), and competency (P = 0.035) compared with online activities. CONCLUSIONS: KUs can be engaged meaningfully in SR processes. Their perceived engagement was higher for in-person than for online activities.
引用
- Soobiah C, Straus SE, Manley G, et al. Engaging knowledge users in a systematic review on the comparative effectiveness of geriatrician-led models of care is possible: A cross-sectional survey using the Patient Engagement Evaluation Tool. J Clin Epidemiol. 2019. PMID: 31129259. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2019.05.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。