文献速递临床试验与 GCP流行病学与生物统计

社区与诊所依从性俱乐部对接受抗逆转录病毒治疗患者失访和病毒抑制的影响:南非一项实用性随机对照试验的发现

The impact of community- versus clinic-based adherence clubs on loss from care and viral suppression for antiretroviral therapy patients: Findings from a pragmatic randomized controlled trial in South Africa.
PubMed 文献 · PLoS Med · 2019-05-21

在南非约翰内斯堡一家诊所,775名病毒载量检测不到的ART患者按1:1随机分入诊所或社区依从性俱乐部,每两个月活动一次。社区组失访累积比例52%(95%CI 47%-57%),高于诊所组43%(95%CI 38%-48%,p=0.002);校正后社区组失访风险更高(aHR 1.38,95%CI 1.02-1.87,p=0.032)。

要点

  • 社区组失访52%,诊所组43%,社区组失访风险更高(aHR 1.38)。
  • 失访最常见原因是完全错过俱乐部活动和取药(54%)。
  • 两组俱乐部护理期间均无死亡,病毒反弹社区组13% vs 诊所组21%(p=0.051)。

核心结论

  • 在该研究环境中,依从性俱乐部干预的总体失访率较高,社区依从性俱乐部的失访情况比诊所依从性俱乐部更差。
  • 作者提醒,在未更好理解与成功保留在 care 相关的患者层面因素之前,不应假设诊所干预的有效性会自动延续到社区环境。

研究设计与样本

  • 实用性随机对照试验,在南非约翰内斯堡Witkoppen Health and Welfare Centre开展。
  • 2014年2月12日至2015年5月31日,将病毒载量检测不到的ART成人患者按1:1随机分入诊所或社区依从性俱乐部,共775例:诊所组376例(49%),社区组399例(51%)。
  • 俱乐部每两个月活动一次;所有参与者每年在诊所接受病毒载量监测和医学检查。
  • 若错过俱乐部访视且5天内未取ART药物、连续2次延迟取药、出现排除性合并症或病毒反弹,则转回诊所标准护理。

主要发现

  • 总体47%(95%CI 44%-51%)发生主要结局即俱乐部护理失访。
  • 社区组失访累积比例52%(95%CI 47%-57%),诊所组43%(95%CI 38%-48%),p=0.002。
  • 校正性别、年龄、国籍、ART治疗时间、基线CD4计数和就业状态后,社区组失访风险高于诊所组(aHR 1.38,95%CI 1.02-1.87,p=0.032)。
  • 367例失访者中最常见原因是完全错过俱乐部访视及相应ART取药(54%,95%CI 49%-59%),两组相似(p=0.086)。
  • 失访者中3%发生排除性合并症,两组无差异(p=0.816);俱乐部护理期间两组均无死亡。

临床怎么用

  • 原文结论未据此给出临床推荐;作者提醒不应假设诊所干预的有效性会自动延续到社区环境。

局限性

  • 缺乏接受常规诊所标准护理的对照组。
  • 单诊所设置可能导致普遍性有限。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Adherence clubs, where groups of 25-30 patients who are virally suppressed on antiretroviral therapy (ART) meet for counseling and medication pickup, represent an innovative model to retain patients in care and facilitate task-shifting. This intervention replaces traditional clinical care encounters with a 1-hour group session every 2-3 months, and can be organized at a clinic or a community venue. We performed a pragmatic randomized controlled trial to compare loss from club-based care between community- and clinic-based adherence clubs. METHODS AND FINDINGS: Patients on ART with undetectable viral load at Witkoppen Health and Welfare Centre in Johannesburg, South Africa, were randomized 1:1 to a clinic- or community-based adherence club. Clubs were held every other month. All participants received annual viral load monitoring and medical exam at the clinic. Participants were referred back to clinic-based standard care if they missed a club visit and did not pick up ART medications within 5 days, had 2 consecutive late ART medication pickups, developed a disqualifying (excluding) comorbidity, or had viral rebound. From February 12, 2014, to May 31, 2015, we randomized 775 eligible adults into 12 pairs of clubs-376 (49%) into clinic-based clubs and 399 (51%) into community-based clubs. Characteristics were similar by arm: 65% female, median age 38 years, and median CD4 count 506 cells/mm3. Overall, 47% (95% CI 44%-51%) experienced the primary outcome of loss from club-based care. Among community-based club participants, the cumulative proportion lost from club-based care was 52% (95% CI 47%-57%), compared to 43% (95% CI 38%-48%, p = 0.002) among clinic-based club participants. The risk of loss to club-based care was higher among participants assigned to community-based clubs than among those assigned to clinic-based clubs (adjusted hazard ratio 1.38, 95% CI 1.02-1.87, p = 0.032), after accounting for sex, age, nationality, time on ART, baseline CD4 count, and employment status. Among those who were lost from club-based care (n = 367), the most common reason was missing a club visit and the associated ART medication pickup entirely (54%, 95% CI 49%-59%), and was similar by arm (p = 0.086). Development of an excluding comorbidity occurred in 3% overall of those lost from club-based care, and was not different by arm (p = 0.816); no deaths occurred in either arm during club-based care. Viral rebound occurred in 13% of those lost from community club-based care and 21% of those lost from clinic-based care (p = 0.051). In post hoc secondary analysis, among those referred to standard care, 72% (95% CI 68%-77%) reengaged in clinic-based care within 90 days of their club-based care discontinuation date. The main limitations of the trial are the lack of a comparison group receiving routine clinic-based standard care and the potential limited generalizability due to the single-clinic setting. CONCLUSIONS: These findings demonstrate that overall loss from an adherence club intervention was high in this setting and that, importantly, it was worse in community-based adherence clubs compared to those based at the clinic. We urge caution in assuming that the effectiveness of clinic-based interventions will carry over to community settings, without a better understanding of patient-level factors associated with successful retention in care. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Pan African Clinical Trials Registry (PACTR201602001460157).

来源:PLoS Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hanrahan CF, Schwartz SR, Mudavanhu M, et al. The impact of community- versus clinic-based adherence clubs on loss from care and viral suppression for antiretroviral therapy patients: Findings from a pragmatic randomized controlled trial in South Africa. PLoS Med. 2019. PMID: 31112543. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1002808

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。