推拿手法治疗对比常规照护治疗非急性下腰痛的比较有效性:一项先导性随机对照试验
本研究为三臂、多中心、实用性、随机对照先导试验,于2016年3月28日至2016年9月19日在四家医疗机构开展,共纳入60例非急性下腰痛患者,随机分为推拿手法治疗组(n=20)、常规照护组(n=20)和联合治疗组(n=20),治疗6周。主要结局为下腰痛强度数字评分量表(NRS),结果显示三组间下腰痛NRS评分变化和Oswestry功能障碍指数(ODI)评分变化均有显著差异(P<0.01),其他次要结局变化无显著差异,报告16例次轻至中度安全性问题。作者认为推拿手法治疗对非急性下腰痛具有比较有效性且总体安全,并将开展样本量超过192例的两臂验证试验。
要点
- 推拿手法治疗组下腰痛NRS评分平均降低3.28(95%CI -4.08, -2.47),常规照护组降低1.95(-2.82, -1.08),联合治疗组降低1.75(-2.70, -0.80),三组间差异P<0.01。
- 推拿手法治疗组ODI评分平均降低12.29(95%CI -16.86, -7.72),常规照护组降低10.34(-14.63, -6.06),联合治疗组降低9.27(-14.28, -4.26),三组间差异P<0.01。
- 其他次要结局变化三组间无显著差异,报告16例次轻至中度安全性问题,作者认为推拿手法治疗对非急性下腰痛具有比较有效性且总体安全。
核心结论
- 作者认为推拿手法治疗对非急性下腰痛具有比较有效性且总体安全。
- 作者指出本研究为先导性研究,将开展样本量超过192例的两臂(推拿手法治疗对比常规照护)验证试验以评估结果的普遍性。
研究设计与样本
- 三臂、多中心、实用性、随机对照先导试验,于2016年3月28日至2016年9月19日在四家医疗机构开展。
- 共60例患者随机分配至推拿手法治疗组(n=20)、常规照护组(n=20)或联合治疗组(n=20),接受相关治疗6周。
- 意向性分析纳入60例患者,符合方案分析纳入55例(推拿手法治疗组18例、常规照护组18例、联合治疗组19例),脱落率5.3%。
主要发现
- 治疗期间下腰痛NRS评分变化三组间有显著差异:推拿手法治疗组平均-3.28(95%CI -4.08, -2.47),常规照护组-1.95(-2.82, -1.08),联合治疗组-1.75(-2.70, -0.80),P<0.01。
- ODI评分变化三组间有显著差异:推拿手法治疗组平均-12.29(95%CI -16.86, -7.72),常规照护组-10.34(-14.63, -6.06),联合治疗组-9.27(-14.28, -4.26),P<0.01。
- 其他次要结局变化三组间无显著差异。
- 报告16例次轻至中度安全性问题。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文指出本研究为先导性研究,将开展样本量超过192例的两臂(推拿手法治疗对比常规照护)验证试验以评估结果的普遍性。
- 原文报告脱落率5.3%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Low back pain (LBP) is common, with a lifetime prevalence of 80%, and as such it places substantial social and economic burden on individuals and society. Chuna manual therapy (CMT) combines aspects of physiology, biodynamics of spine and joint motion, and basic theory of movement dynamics. This study aimed to test the comparative effectiveness and safety of CMT for non-acute LBP. METHODS: A three-arm, multicenter, pragmatic, randomized controlled pilot trial was conducted from 28 March 2016 to 19 September 2016, at four medical institutions. A total of 60 patients were randomly allocated to the CMT group (n = 20), usual care (UC) group (n = 20), or combined treatment (CMT + UC) group (n = 20), and received the relevant treatments for 6 weeks. The primary outcome was a numeric rating scale (NRS) representation of LBP intensity, while secondary outcomes included NRS of leg pain, Oswestry disability index (ODI), Patient Global Impression of Change (PGIC), the EuroQol-5 dimensions (EQ-5D), lumbar range of motion, and safety. RESULTS: A total of 60 patients were included in the intention-to-treat analysis and 55 patients (CMT, 18; UC, 18; CMT + UC, 19) were included in the per-protocol analysis (drop-out rate 5.3%). Over the treatment period there were significant differences in the NRS score for LBP (CMT mean - 3.28 (95% CI - 4.08, - 2.47); UC - 1.95 (- 2.82, - 1.08); CMT + UC - 1.75 (- 2.70, - 0.80), P < 0.01) and the ODI scores in each group (CMT - 12.29 (- 16.86, - 7.72); UC - 10.34 (- 14.63, - 6.06); CMT + UC - 9.27 (- 14.28, - 4.26), P < 0.01). The changes in other secondary outcomes did not significantly differ among the three groups. Sixteen minor-to-moderate safety concerns were reported. CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that CMT has comparative efficacy for non-acute LBP and is generally safe. As this was a preliminary study, a well-powered (over 192 participants) two-arm (CMT versus UC) verification trial will be performed to assess the generalizability of these results. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Clinical Research Information Service (CRIS), KCT0001850 . Registered on 12 March 2016.
引用
- Lim KT, Hwang EH, Cho JH, et al. Comparative effectiveness of Chuna manual therapy versus conventional usual care for non-acute low back pain: a pilot randomized controlled trial. Trials. 2019. PMID: 30987662. doi:10.1186/s13063-019-3302-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。