非Cochrane系统评价与其已发表方案的方法学差异比较:差异频繁出现但鲜有解释
该研究检索MEDLINE和Embase中2012至2013年发表的80篇非Cochrane系统评价及其方案,比较两者在PRISMA-P方法学条目上的差异。结果显示92.5%的系统评价至少在一个方法学条目上与方案不同,48.8%存在重大差异,平均每篇差异3.2个条目,仅10%的差异在系统评价中被报告,其中三分之二给出了解释。
要点
- 92.5%的非Cochrane系统评价至少在一个方法学PRISMA-P条目上与方案存在差异。
- 48.8%的系统评价至少在一个条目上存在重大差异,平均每篇差异3.2个条目。
- 仅10%的差异在系统评价中被报告,其中三分之二给出解释(占总差异的7.0%)。
核心结论
- 非Cochrane系统评价的报告质量与透明度有待提高,作者应在系统评价发表时报告并解释对方案所做的所有重要更改,更新的PRISMA声明应纳入相关指导。
研究设计与样本
- 研究检索MEDLINE和Embase,识别2012年至2013年发表的80篇非Cochrane系统评价的方案,并采用多种方法检索截至2016年12月的对应系统评价,按PRISMA-P方法学条目(第7至17条及其子类)比较系统评价与方案的差异。
主要发现
- 几乎全部系统评价(92.5%)在至少一个方法学PRISMA-P条目(第7至17条)及其子类上与方案存在差异。
- 半数系统评价(48.8%)在至少一个条目上存在重大差异。
- 平均每篇系统评价与方案在3.2个条目上存在差异,其中1个条目包含重大差异。
- 所有差异中仅10%在系统评价中被报告,其中三分之二给出了解释(占总差异的7.0%)。
临床怎么用
- 作者应在系统评价发表时报告并解释对方案所做的所有重要更改。
- 更新的PRISMA声明应纳入关于报告和解释方案更改的指导。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To quantify the prevalence of differences in the reported methods between non-Cochrane systematic reviews (SRs) and their protocols and the extent to which these were reported and explained. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We searched MEDLINE and Embase to identify protocols of non-Cochrane SRs published in 2012 and 2013. Using various methods, we searched for their corresponding SRs up to December 2016. The SRs and protocols were compared with respect to the methods-related "Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic review and Meta-Analysis Protocols" (PRISMA-P). RESULTS: We included 80 SRs and their protocols. Almost all SRs (92.5%) differed from their protocols in at least one of the methods-related PRISMA-P items (no. 7-17) and their subcategories. Half the SRs (48.8%) had a major difference in at least one item. On average, each SR differed from its protocol in 3.2 items, of which one comprised a major difference. Only 10% of all differences were reported in the SR, two-thirds with an explanation (7.0% in total). CONCLUSION: The reporting quality and transparency of non-Cochrane SRs requires further improvement. Authors should report and explain all important changes made to the protocol in the SR publication. The updated PRISMA statement should include guidance regarding this matter.
引用
- Koensgen N, Rombey T, Allers K, et al. Comparison of non-Cochrane systematic reviews and their published protocols: differences occurred frequently but were seldom explained. J Clin Epidemiol. 2019. PMID: 30822507. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2019.02.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。