德尔菲法中评分量表与共识标准对核心结局集结局选择的影响
结果显示九点量表组被评为「关键」的结局数几乎为三点量表组的两倍(24 vs. 13),更严格及组合的共识标准导致更少结局被认定为「关键」。结论认为评分量表格式与共识标准定义会影响结局选择。
要点
- 九点量表较三点量表使更多结局被评为「关键」(24 vs. 13)。
- 更严格或组合的共识标准减少被认定为「关键」的结局数。
- 九点量表或可用于后续评分或面对面会议前的共识信息准备。
核心结论
- 德尔菲研究中评分量表的格式与共识标准的定义会影响核心结局集的结局选择。
- 九点量表可能被推荐用于为后续评分或面对面会议提供共识过程的信息。
- 三点量表可能在确定最终共识时更受偏好。
研究设计与样本
- 在失禁相关性皮炎核心结局集项目的首轮德尔菲中开展随机对照平行组试验,按1:1分配。
- 结局分别采用三点或九点Likert量表评分。
- 采用常用共识标准(比例与限制范围组合、特定范围内的集中趋势、方差下降)决定保留哪些结局。
主要发现
- 九点量表组被评为「关键」的结局数几乎为三点量表组的两倍(24 vs. 13)。
- 更严格的共识标准以及组合共识标准导致更少结局被识别为「关键」。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识标准包括比例与限制范围的组合、特定范围内的集中趋势以及方差下降。
- 九点量表组24个结局被评为「关键」,三点量表组13个被评为「关键」。
临床怎么用
- 在核心结局集开发的德尔菲过程中,选择评分量表格式和共识标准定义时需考虑其对结局选择的影响。
- 可考虑使用九点量表为后续评分或面对面会议提供共识过程信息,三点量表用于确定最终共识。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to compare two different rating scales within one Delphi study for defining consensus in core outcome set development and to explore the influence of consensus criteria on the outcome selection. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Randomized controlled parallel group trial with 1:1 allocation within the first Delphi round of the Core Outcome Set in the Incontinence-Associated Dermatitis project. Outcomes were rated on a three-point or nine-point Likert scale. Decisions about which outcomes to retain were determined by commonly used consensus criteria (i.e., [combinations of] proportions with restricted ranges, central tendency within a specific range, and decrease in variance). RESULTS: Fifty-seven participants (group 1 = 28, group 2 = 29) rated 58 outcomes. The use of the nine-point scale resulted in almost twice as many outcomes being rated as "critical" compared with the three-point scale (24 vs. 13). Stricter criteria and combining criteria led to less outcomes being identified as "critical". CONCLUSION: The format of rating scales in Delphi studies for core outcome set development and the definition of the consensus criteria influence outcome selection. The use of the nine-point scale might be recommended to inform the consensus process for a subsequent rating or face-to-face meeting. The three-point scale might be preferred when determining final consensus.
引用
- De Meyer D, Kottner J, Beele H, et al. Delphi procedure in core outcome set development: rating scale and consensus criteria determined outcome selection. J Clin Epidemiol. 2019. PMID: 30922885. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2019.03.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。