埃塞俄比亚生物医学与公共卫生综述及荟萃分析的方法学质量较差:1970至2018年证据概览
该概览纳入1970至2018年间与埃塞俄比亚相关的106篇叙述性综述和系统综述,评估其方法学质量。结果显示叙述性综述中55.3%、系统综述中75%方法学质量较差,仅少数系统综述注册方案或报告纳入研究设计依据。
要点
- 埃塞俄比亚相关综述发表量上升,但方法学质量普遍不佳。
- 系统综述中仅10.4%注册方案,8.3%说明纳入研究设计依据。
- 叙述性综述中55.3%、系统综述中75%方法学质量较差。
核心结论
- 埃塞俄比亚相关叙述性综述和系统综述发表率上升,但约半数叙述性综述和四分之三系统综述方法学质量较差。
研究设计与样本
- 概览纳入1970至2018年间所有与埃塞俄比亚相关的叙述性综述及系统综述(含或不含荟萃分析),不限发表地和作者单位。
- 共纳入106篇文章,其中叙述性综述54篇(50.9%),系统综述17篇(16%),含荟萃分析的系统综述35篇(33.1%)。
- 使用International Narrative Systematic Assessment评估叙述性综述,使用A MeaSurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews评估系统综述。
- 采用Fisher精确检验(P值阈值0.05)探究方法学质量的相关因素。
主要发现
- 48篇系统综述(含或不含荟萃分析)中,仅5篇(10.4%)注册了方案。
- 48篇系统综述中仅4篇(8.3%)说明了纳入研究设计选择的依据。
- 48篇系统综述中无一报告原始研究的资助来源。
- 55.3%的叙述性综述和75%的系统综述(含或不含荟萃分析)方法学质量较差。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The aims of this overview are to assess the trend of narrative and systematic reviews in Ethiopia, examine their methodological quality, and suggest future directions for improvement. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: All narrative reviews and systematic reviews with or without a meta-analysis on topics associated with Ethiopia irrespective of the place of publication and authors' affiliation were included. The International Narrative Systematic Assessment for narrative reviews and A MeaSurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews for systematic reviews with or without a meta-analysis were used for quality appraisal. Fisher's exact test at the P-value threshold of 0.05 was used to investigate associated factors of methodological quality. RESULTS: Of 106 articles reviewed, 54 (50.9%) were narrative reviews, 17 (16%) were systematic reviews, and 35 (33.1%) were systematic reviews with meta-analyses. Among 48 systematic reviews with or without meta-analysis, only five (10.4%) registered their protocol, four (8.3%) justified the selection of the study design for inclusion, and none of them reported sources of funding for the primary studies. Overall, 55.3% of narrative reviews and 75% of systematic reviews with or without meta-analysis had poor methodological quality. CONCLUSIONS: Although publication rate of narrative and systematic reviews has risen in Ethiopia, half of the narrative reviews and three-quarters of the systematic reviews had poor methodological quality.
引用
- Habtewold TD, Alemu SM, Mohammed SH, et al. Biomedical and public health reviews and meta-analyses in Ethiopia had poor methodological quality: overview of evidence from 1970 to 2018. J Clin Epidemiol. 2019. PMID: 30721723. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2019.01.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。