在儿科试验中开展SWAT项目面临的挑战与经验
本文描述了在英国儿科临床试验中嵌入「试验内研究」(SWAT)项目时遇到的实际困难,包括治理审批、数据共享、经费、网络条件及伦理问题,并指出儿科场景下的伦理顾虑更为突出,呼吁通过多方宣传和探索替代资助模式来推动SWAT更顺畅地实施。
要点
- SWAT嵌入儿科试验面临治理审批与匿名数据共享等流程障碍。
- 宿主试验经费、医疗场所网络质量与可及性构成实际限制。
- 儿科SWAT的伦理顾虑可能更突出,需多方宣传与替代资助模式。
核心结论
- SWAT正日益用于为改善试验效率提供证据基础,但嵌入TRECA时遇到了此前文献未报告的多种意外挑战。
- 若通过面向所有关键利益相关方的广泛宣传与解释,并探索SWAT的替代资助模式,可望使SWAT流程更顺畅、适时并形成更强证据基础。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为主旨论述,描述在英国儿科临床试验中开展SWAT项目所遇挑战,并以TRECA研究作为嵌入案例。
- TRECA研究旨在开发多媒体网站,用于在儿科试验中向儿童、青少年及其家庭提供招募信息。
- TRECA研究已在ISRCTN注册,ID为73136092,注册日期为2016年8月24日。
主要发现
- 遇到的挑战包括治理问题,如宿主试验审批流程与匿名数据共享。
- 经费问题涉及宿主试验的资助。
- 医疗场所内的网络质量与可及性构成挑战。
- 与SWAT方法学相关的伦理顾虑被提及,且在儿科场景下可能更为突出。
- 作者推测伦理顾虑更突出可能与儿科SWAT开展较少或对儿童研究采取更谨慎、规避风险的态度有关。
临床怎么用
- 在儿科试验中规划SWAT时,应提前与治理与伦理相关方沟通审批与数据共享安排。
- 需评估医疗场所网络条件并落实宿主试验经费与替代资助来源。
- 推动面向所有关键利益相关方的SWAT宣传与解释,以减少实施障碍。
局限性
- 本文为主旨论述,所报告的挑战基于作者在英国儿科试验中开展SWAT项目的经验,非系统评价。
- 文中关于伦理顾虑在儿科更突出的判断为作者推测性解释,未提供定量比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Randomised controlled trials are considered the best method for determining the effectiveness and safety of health interventions. Trials involving children are essential to ensure that treatments are safe and effective. However, many trials, in both adult and paediatric populations, do not achieve recruitment targets and/or maintain retention of participants, which can lead to a reduction in the internal and external validity of the results. Identifying ways of improving trial efficiency are important in order to increase the successful completion of trials. MAIN BODY: A 'Study Within A Trial' (SWAT) is a self-contained study embedded within an ongoing trial, which aims to establish evidence to improve the management and delivery of trials in healthcare. Increasing numbers of SWATs have been undertaken in recent years yet very few within paediatric trials. Herein, we describe some of the challenges with undertaking a programme of SWATs within paediatric clinical trials in the UK. The TRECA (TRials Engagement in Children and Adolescents) study involves developing multimedia websites for use within paediatric trials to provide recruitment information to children, young people and their families about the clinical trial. Challenges encountered included governance issues such as host trial approval processes and sharing of anonymised data, funding issues for host trials, internet quality and accessibility within the healthcare setting, and ethical concerns associated with SWAT methodology. We believe the ethical concerns are more pronounced in the paediatric setting, perhaps because of the fewer SWATs undertaken in these settings or that a more cautious, risk-averse approach to undertaking research with children is taken. CONCLUSION: SWATs are becoming increasingly common to provide an evidence base for methods to improve trial efficiency. However, we encountered a number of unanticipated challenges to embedding TRECA that have not been previously reported within the scientific literature. We believe that, if these issues were addressed through wider promotion and explanation of undertaking SWATs involving all key stakeholders, as well as by exploration of alternative funding models for SWATs, this would enable more streamlined, appropriate and timely processes for SWATs and a stronger evidence base for what works to increase trial efficiency. TRIAL REGISTRATION: The TRECA study is registered on ISRCTN, ID 73136092 . Registered on 24 August 2016.
引用
- Martin-Kerry J, Parker A, Bower P, et al. SWATted away: the challenging experience of setting up a programme of SWATs in paediatric trials. Trials. 2019. PMID: 30782209. doi:10.1186/s13063-019-3236-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。