不同证据摘要对诊断试验荟萃分析情境化的影响
本文基于疑似复发性乳腺癌女性中比较PET、PET/CT与常规检查的决策模型分析,讨论贝叶斯荟萃分析摘要指标(后验均值、后验估计、后验预测均值)在估计诊断试验参数(患病率、灵敏度、特异度)时的选择问题。结果显示均值与预测均值估计相似,但后者不确定性更大,PET/CT平均优于常规检查,但在未来新环境中未必更优。作者提出算法以推荐适合决策模型输入参数的估计量。
要点
- 选择荟萃分析估计量需理解决策情境与研究情境的关系。
- 均值与预测均值估计相似,但预测均值不确定性更大。
- PET/CT平均优于常规检查,未来新环境中未必更优。
核心结论
- 从荟萃分析中选择决策模型参数的估计量,需理解决策情境与荟萃分析研究所处情境的关系,即前者类似某一研究情境、全部研究情境还是代表新情境。
研究设计与样本
- 本文扩展了一项分析,该分析比较了疑似复发性乳腺癌女性中PET、PET/CT与常规检查。
- 讨论贝叶斯荟萃分析摘要(现有研究集合的后验均值、现有研究的后验估计、新研究的后验预测均值)用于估计决策模型所需的诊断试验参数(患病率、灵敏度、特异度)。
主要发现
- 均值与预测均值给出相似估计,但后者显示更大的不确定性。
- PET/CT平均优于常规检查,但在未来环境中实施时可能并不优于常规检查。
临床怎么用
- 作者提供算法,推荐在诊断试验决策模型中选择适当的估计量作为输入参数,以获得与决策情境一致的输出参数。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate diagnostic tests, analysts use meta-analyses to provide inputs to parameters in decision models. Choosing parameter estimands from meta-analyses requires understanding the meta-analytic and decision-making contexts. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We expand on an analysis comparing positron emission tomography (PET), PET with computed tomography (PET/CT), and conventional workup (CW) in women with suspected recurrent breast cancer. We discuss Bayesian meta-analytic summaries (posterior mean over a set of existing studies, posterior estimate in an existing study, posterior predictive mean in a new study) used to estimate diagnostic test parameters (prevalence, sensitivity, specificity) needed to calculate quality-adjusted life years in a decision model contextualizing PET, PET/CT, and CW. RESULTS: The mean and predictive mean give similar estimates, but the latter displays greater uncertainty. Namely, PET/CT outperforms CW on average but may not do better than CW when implemented in future settings. CONCLUSION: Selecting estimands for decision model parameters from meta-analyses requires understanding the relationship between decision settings and meta-analysis studies' settings, specifically whether the former resemble one or all study settings or represents new settings. We provide an algorithm recommending appropriate estimands as input parameters in decision models for diagnostic tests to obtain output parameters consistent with the decision context.
引用
- Zgodic A, Schmid CH, Olkin I, et al. Different evidence summaries have implications for contextualizing findings of meta-analysis of diagnostic tests. J Clin Epidemiol. 2019. PMID: 30654146. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2019.01.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。