跟腱断裂手术与非手术治疗的系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析比较了跟腱断裂手术与非手术治疗后的再断裂率、并发症率及功能结局,并评估早期与晚期完全负重、早期活动度功能康复的影响。手术组再断裂率显著低于非手术组(2.3% vs 3.9%),但并发症率显著更高(4.9% vs 1.6%),主要归因于手术组感染(2.8%)。最终治疗决策应基于患者个体因素和共享决策。
要点
- 手术组再断裂率2.3%,非手术组3.9%,风险差1.6%,手术显著降低再断裂风险。
- 手术组并发症率4.9%,非手术组1.6%,风险差3.3%,主要差异为手术组感染2.8%。
- 采用早期活动度加速功能康复的研究中,手术与非手术再断裂率无显著差异。
核心结论
- 跟腱断裂手术治疗较非手术治疗降低再断裂风险,但再断裂率总体较低且组间差异小(风险差1.6%)。
- 手术治疗增加其他并发症风险(风险差3.3%),最终决策应基于患者个体因素和共享决策。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索PubMed/Medline、Embase、CENTRAL和CINAHL数据库至2018年4月25日。
- 由四名评审员成对独立提取数据,采用随机效应模型合并结局,以风险差、风险比或均数差及95%置信区间呈现。
主要发现
- 手术组再断裂率2.3%,非手术组3.9%(风险差1.6%;风险比0.43,95%CI 0.31-0.60;P<0.001;I2=22%)。
- 手术组并发症率4.9%,非手术组1.6%(风险差3.3%;风险比2.76,95%CI 1.84-4.13;P<0.001;I2=45%),主要差异归因于手术组感染(2.8%)。
- 早期和晚期完全负重下均见手术利于降低再断裂率的相似效应。
- 采用早期活动度加速功能康复的研究中,手术与非手术再断裂率无显著差异(风险比0.60,95%CI 0.26-1.37;P=0.23;I2=0%)。
- 随机对照试验与观察性研究的效应估计无差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 手术组再断裂率2.3%,非手术组3.9%;风险差1.6%,风险比0.43(95%CI 0.31-0.60),P<0.001,I2=22%。
- 手术组并发症率4.9%,非手术组1.6%;风险差3.3%,风险比2.76(95%CI 1.84-4.13),P<0.001,I2=45%;手术组感染率2.8%。
- 早期活动度加速功能康复研究中再断裂风险比0.60(95%CI 0.26-1.37),P=0.23,I2=0%。
临床怎么用
- 跟腱断裂治疗选择需权衡手术降低再断裂与增加并发症(尤其感染)的风险。
- 最终决策应基于患者个体因素并结合共享决策。
- 对于采用早期活动度加速功能康复的患者,手术与非手术再断裂风险差异不显著。
局限性
- 纳入研究以观察性研究为主(占94%患者),随机对照试验样本量较小(944例,占6%)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To compare re-rupture rate, complication rate, and functional outcome after operative versus nonoperative treatment of Achilles tendon ruptures; to compare re-rupture rate after early and late full weight bearing; to evaluate re-rupture rate after functional rehabilitation with early range of motion; and to compare effect estimates from randomised controlled trials and observational studies. DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis. DATA SOURCES: PubMed/Medline, Embase, CENTRAL, and CINAHL databases were last searched on 25 April 2018 for studies comparing operative versus nonoperative treatment of Achilles tendon ruptures. STUDY SELECTION CRITERIA: Randomised controlled trials and observational studies reporting on comparison of operative versus nonoperative treatment of acute Achilles tendon ruptures. DATA EXTRACTION: Data extraction was performed independently in pairs, by four reviewers, with the use of a predefined data extraction file. Outcomes were pooled using random effects models and presented as risk difference, risk ratio, or mean difference, with 95% confidence interval. RESULTS: 29 studies were included-10 randomised controlled trials and 19 observational studies. The 10 trials included 944 (6%) patients, and the 19 observational studies included 14 918 (94%) patients. A significant reduction in re-ruptures was seen after operative treatment (2.3%) compared with nonoperative treatment (3.9%) (risk difference 1.6%; risk ratio 0.43, 95% confidence interval 0.31 to 0.60; P<0.001; I2=22%). Operative treatment resulted in a significantly higher complication rate than nonoperative treatment (4.9% v 1.6%; risk difference 3.3%; risk ratio 2.76, 1.84 to 4.13; P<0.001; I2=45%). The main difference in complication rate was attributable to the incidence of infection (2.8%) in the operative group. A similar reduction in re-rupture rate in favour of operative treatment was seen after both early and late full weight bearing. No significant difference in re-rupture rate was seen between operative and nonoperative treatment in studies that used accelerated functional rehabilitation with early range of motion (risk ratio 0.60, 0.26 to 1.37; P=0.23; I2=0%). No difference in effect estimates was seen between randomised controlled trials and observational studies. CONCLUSIONS: This meta-analysis shows that operative treatment of Achilles tendon ruptures reduces the risk of re-rupture compared with nonoperative treatment. However, re-rupture rates are low and differences between treatment groups are small (risk difference 1.6%). Operative treatment results in a higher risk of other complications (risk difference 3.3%). The final decision on the management of acute Achilles tendon ruptures should be based on patient specific factors and shared decision making. This review emphasises the potential benefits of adding high quality observational studies in meta-analyses for the evaluation of objective outcome measures after surgical treatment.
引用
- Ochen Y, Beks RB, van Heijl M, et al. Operative treatment versus nonoperative treatment of Achilles tendon ruptures: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ. 2019. PMID: 30617123. doi:10.1136/bmj.k5120
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。