基于冠状动脉造影的机器学习评估心肌缺血:开发与回顾性验证
该回顾性研究利用1132例接受有创冠状动脉造影、FFR及CCTA的中间病变患者数据,开发基于造影的机器学习算法预测狭窄段供血心肌体积,并构建识别FFR<0.80病变的分类器。测试集准确率约80%(AUC 0.84-0.87),外部验证准确率84%(AUC 0.89),均优于直径狭窄>53%的评估。
要点
- 基于造影的机器学习可预测狭窄段供血心肌体积,缓解造影与FFR的视觉-功能不匹配。
- 机器学习分类器识别FFR<0.80病变的准确率约80%,外部验证达84%。
- 直径狭窄>53%预测FFR<0.80的准确率仅66%,机器学习模型表现更优。
核心结论
- 基于造影的机器学习有助于预测供血心肌区域及缺血性病变,缓解造影与FFR之间的视觉-功能不匹配。
- 临床实用性仍需在大样本前瞻性队列中进一步验证。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入韩国Asan医学中心2012年5月至2015年11月1132例稳定或不稳定心绞痛患者的1132个中间病变,均接受有创冠状动脉造影、FFR和CCTA。
- 932例(2015年1月31日前评估)为训练集,200例(2015年2月1日后评估)为测试集,另用两中心79例进行外部验证。
- 采用定量冠状动脉造影和CCTA心肌分割测量各血管供血心肌体积及狭窄段供血心肌体积作为标签。
主要发现
- 基于造影的机器学习(轻量梯度提升机)预测CAMS-%LAD、CAMS-%LCX、CAMS-%RCA的平均绝对误差分别为5.42%、8.57%、4.54%。
- 5折交叉验证中,弹性网使ML-%Vsub与CAMS-%Vsub的平均绝对误差最小:LAD为6.26%±0.55%,LCX为5.79%±0.68%,RCA为2.95%±0.14%。
- 测试集中机器学习分类器预测FFR<0.80的准确率约80%(AUC=0.84-0.87,95%CI 0.71-0.94),优于直径狭窄>53%的66%(AUC=0.71,95%CI 0.65-0.78)。
- 外部验证准确率84%(AUC=0.89,95%CI 0.83-0.95)。
关键数值与推荐
- 预测FFR<0.80的机器学习分类器包括L2惩罚逻辑回归、支持向量机和随机森林,使用年龄、性别、病变血管段及影响心肌区域和狭窄程度的造影特征。
- 直径狭窄>53%预测FFR<0.80的准确率为66%(AUC=0.71,95%CI 0.65-0.78)。
- 外部验证的准确率为84%(AUC=0.89,95%CI 0.83-0.95)。
临床怎么用
- 对于冠状动脉造影中的中间病变,可尝试基于造影的机器学习辅助评估缺血风险,减少对FFR的依赖。
- 该模型可能帮助识别视觉评估与功能评估不匹配的病变,优化治疗决策。
局限性
- 回顾性设计可能限制预测模型的推广应用。
- 单一种族人群。
- 缺乏临床结局数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Invasive fractional flow reserve (FFR) is a standard tool for identifying ischemia-producing coronary stenosis. However, in clinical practice, over 70% of treatment decisions still rely on visual estimation of angiographic stenosis, which has limited accuracy (about 60%-65%) for the prediction of FFR < 0.80. One of the reasons for the visual-functional mismatch is that myocardial ischemia can be affected by the supplied myocardial size, which is not always evident by coronary angiography. The aims of this study were to develop an angiography-based machine learning (ML) algorithm for predicting the supplied myocardial volume for a stenosis, as measured using coronary computed tomography angiography (CCTA), and then to build an angiography-based classifier for the lesions with an FFR < 0.80 versus ≥ 0.80. METHODS AND FINDINGS: A retrospective study was conducted using data from 1,132 stable and unstable angina patients with 1,132 intermediate lesions who underwent invasive coronary angiography, FFR, and CCTA at the Asan Medical Center, Seoul, Korea, between 1 May 2012 and 30 November 2015. The mean age was 63 ± 10 years, 76% were men, and 72% of the patients presented with stable angina. Of these, 932 patients (assessed before 31 January 2015) constituted the training set for the algorithm, and 200 patients (assessed after 1 February 2015) served as a test cohort to validate its diagnostic performance. Additionally, external validation with 79 patients from two centers (CHA University, Seongnam, Korea, and Ajou University, Suwon, Korea) was conducted. After automatic contour calibration using the caliber of guiding catheter, quantitative coronary angiography was performed using the edge-detection algorithms (CAAS-5, Pie-Medical). Clinical information was provided by the Asan BiomedicaL Research Environment (ABLE) system. The CCTA-based myocardial segmentation (CAMS)-derived myocardial volume supplied by each vessel (right coronary artery [RCA], left anterior descending [LAD], left circumflex [LCX]) and the myocardial volume subtended to a stenotic segment (CAMS-%Vsub) were measured for labeling. The ML for (1) predicting vessel territories (CAMS-%LAD, CAMS-%LCX, and CAMS-%RCA) and CAMS-%Vsub and (2) identifying the lesions with an FFR < 0.80 was constructed. Angiography-based ML, employing a light gradient boosting machine (GBM), showed mean absolute errors (MAEs) of 5.42%, 8.57%, and 4.54% for predicting CAMS-%LAD, CAMS-%LCX, and CAMS-%RCA, respectively. The percent myocardial volumes predicted by ML were used to predict the CAMS-%Vsub. With 5-fold cross validation, the MAEs between ML-predicted percent myocardial volume subtended to a stenotic segment (ML-%Vsub) and CAMS-%Vsub were minimized by the elastic net (6.26% ± 0.55% for LAD, 5.79% ± 0.68% for LCX, and 2.95% ± 0.14% for RCA lesions). Using all attributes (age, sex, involved vessel segment, and angiographic features affecting the myocardial territory and stenosis degree), the ML classifiers (L2 penalized logistic regression, support vector machine, and random forest) predicted an FFR < 0.80 with an accuracy of approximately 80% (area under the curve [AUC] = 0.84-0.87, 95% confidence intervals 0.71-0.94) in the test set, which was greater than that of diameter stenosis (DS) > 53% (66%, AUC = 0.71, 95% confidence intervals 0.65-0.78). The external validation showed 84% accuracy (AUC = 0.89, 95% confidence intervals 0.83-0.95). The retrospective design, single ethnicity, and the lack of clinical outcomes may limit this prediction model's generalized application. CONCLUSION: We found that angiography-based ML is useful to predict subtended myocardial territories and ischemia-producing lesions by mitigating the visual-functional mismatch between angiographic and FFR. Assessment of clinical utility requires further validation in a large, prospective cohort study.
引用
- Hae H, Kang SJ, Kim WJ, et al. Machine learning assessment of myocardial ischemia using angiography: Development and retrospective validation. PLoS Med. 2018. PMID: 30422987. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1002693
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。