文献速递流行病学与生物统计医学教育与科研方法

社区抗生素使用与耐药性前瞻性研究报道质量分析

An analysis of reporting quality of prospective studies examining community antibiotic use and resistance.
PubMed 文献 · Trials · 2018-11-27

该研究评估了调查社区个体抗生素暴露后耐药性的前瞻性研究的报道质量,纳入17项随机试验和8项队列研究,使用基于现有指南开发的检查表由两名研究者独立评估。结果显示,试验中强制性条目充分描述的平均百分比为59%,队列研究为52%;多数研究未报告各时间点耐药与敏感菌株的具体数量,盲法和样本量计算在近半数试验和所有队列研究中报道不足。结论认为这些研究的报道质量参差不齐,超过半数研究缺失部分细节,妨碍了偏倚风险评估和结果的准确解释与合成。

要点

  • 前瞻性研究报道抗生素暴露与社区耐药关系时,强制性条目充分描述比例试验为59%、队列为52%。
  • 多数研究未报告各时间点分析的耐药与敏感菌株的具体数量。
  • 盲法和样本量计算在近半数试验及所有队列研究中报道不足。

核心结论

  • 调查社区抗生素暴露与耐药菌株分离之间关联的前瞻性研究,其报道质量参差不齐。
  • 超过半数研究缺失部分细节,妨碍了完整的偏倚风险评估及结果的准确解释与合成。

研究设计与样本

  • 评估性研究,纳入系统综述中识别的17项随机试验和8项队列研究。
  • 由两名研究者独立使用基于现有报道指南开发的检查表(试验和队列研究各一套)评估报道质量。

主要发现

  • 强制性条目充分描述的平均百分比(标准差,最小值-最大值):试验为59%(14%,36-84%),队列研究为52%(17%,13-70%)。
  • 多数研究充分描述了研究背景与理由、抗生素干预的类型、联合和持续时间,以及分离耐药菌的采样程序。
  • 多数研究未报告各时间点分析的耐药与敏感菌株的具体数量。
  • 盲法和样本量计算在近半数试验和所有队列研究中报道不足。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Antibiotic resistance is a global problem, but the relationship between antibiotic use and resistance development and decay is not well understood. This knowledge is best provided by prospective studies, but to be useful they must be both conducted and reported well. Little is known about the reporting quality of these studies. This study aimed to assess the quality of reporting in prospective studies that investigated antibiotic resistance following antibiotic exposure in community-based individuals. METHODS: The quality of reporting of prospective studies (17 randomised trials, eight cohort studies) identified in a systematic review of the relationship between antibiotic use and resistance were assessed independently by two researchers using checklists (one for trials, one for cohort studies) developed from existing reporting guidelines for these designs and this field. RESULTS: The mean percentage (SD, minimum-maximum) of mandatory items that were adequately described by the included studies was 59% for trials (14%, 36-84%) and 52% for cohort studies (17%, 13-70%). Most studies adequately described the study background and rationale, the type, combination, and duration of the antibiotic intervention, and the sampling procedures followed to isolate resistant bacteria. Most studies did not report the incident numbers of resistant and susceptible isolates analysed at each time point. Blinding and sample size calculation was inadequately reported in almost half of the trials and all cohort studies. CONCLUSIONS: The quality of reporting in prospective studies investigating the association between antibiotic exposure in the community and isolation of resistance isolates is variable. Some details were missing in more than half of the studies, which precludes a complete risk of bias assessment and accurate interpretation and synthesis of results.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bakhit M, Del Mar C, Scott AM, et al. An analysis of reporting quality of prospective studies examining community antibiotic use and resistance. Trials. 2018. PMID: 30482238. doi:10.1186/s13063-018-3040-6

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。