横断面文献计量研究显示期刊对STROBE及其扩展版的支持率欠佳
该横断面文献计量研究检索了2007至2017年间七个与STROBE扩展版相关领域发表观察性研究的期刊,共纳入257本期刊,提取其关于STROBE、七项扩展版、CONSORT、PRISMA及透明报告相关组织文件的文本。结果显示仅5%期刊要求提交时使用STROBE,9%建议使用,28%间接提及,54%未提及STROBE;相关扩展版仅不足1%期刊要求使用。STROBE支持与期刊影响因子无关,但与CONSORT和PRISMA支持相关。结论认为报告指南支持率低且信息模糊分散,需明确语言以提高依从性和报告质量。
要点
- 仅5%期刊要求提交时使用STROBE,54%未提及STROBE。
- 相关STROBE扩展版仅不足1%期刊要求使用。
- STROBE支持与期刊影响因子无关,但与CONSORT和PRISMA支持相关。
核心结论
- 期刊对报告指南的支持率低,相关信息模糊且分散,需明确语言以提高指南依从性和报告质量。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面文献计量研究,依据已发表方案定义检索策略,识别2007至2017年间七个与STROBE扩展版相关领域发表观察性研究的期刊,共纳入257本独特期刊。
- 提取期刊关于STROBE、七项STROBE扩展版、CONSORT、PRISMA及透明报告相关组织文件(ICMJE、COPE、EQUATOR网络)的文本。
- 使用卡方检验和Mann-Whitney检验分析支持STROBE、支持其他指南与期刊影响因子之间的关系。
主要发现
- 257本期刊中,12本(5%)要求提交时使用STROBE,22本(9%)建议使用,12本(5%)推荐使用「相关指南」,72本(28%)间接提及(通过编辑政策或ICMJE推荐),139本(54%)未提及STROBE。
- 相关STROBE扩展版被2本(<1%)期刊要求使用,4本(1%)期刊建议使用。
- STROBE支持与期刊影响指数无关,但与CONSORT和PRISMA支持相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 257本期刊中,5%要求STROBE,9%建议使用,5%推荐「相关指南」,28%间接提及,54%未提及。
- 相关扩展版被<1%期刊要求使用,1%期刊建议使用。
临床怎么用
- 提示向相关期刊投稿时需主动遵循STROBE及其扩展版,不应仅依赖期刊要求。
- 期刊编辑和出版方应采用明确语言要求使用报告指南,以提升观察性研究报告质量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The STrengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) statement provides guidance on reporting observational studies. Many extensions have been created for specialized methods or fields. We determined endorsement prevalence and typology by journals in extension-related fields. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A published protocol defined search strategies to identify journals publishing observational studies (2007-2017) across seven fields relating to STROBE extensions. We extracted text regarding STROBE, seven STROBE extensions, reporting guidelines Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials and Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses, and transparent reporting documents/groups: International Committee of Medical Journal Editors, Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), and the Enhancing the QUAlity and Transparency Of health Research (EQUATOR) networks. Relationships between endorsing STROBE, endorsing other guidelines, and journal impact factor were tested using chi square and Mann-Whitney tests. RESULTS: Of 257 unique journals, 12 (5%) required STROBE on submission, 22 (9%) suggested use, 12 (5%) recommended a "relevant guideline," 72 (28%) mentioned it indirectly (via editorial policies or International Committee of Medical Journal Editors recommendations), and 139 (54%) did not mention STROBE. The relevant extension was required by 2 (<1%) journals; 4 (1%) suggested use. STROBE endorsement was not associated with journal impact indices but was with Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials and Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses endorsements. CONCLUSION: Reporting guideline endorsement rates are low; information is vague and scattered. Unambiguous language is needed to improve adherence to reporting guidelines and increase the quality of reporting.
引用
- Sharp MK, Tokalić R, Gómez G, et al. A cross-sectional bibliometric study showed suboptimal journal endorsement rates of STROBE and its extensions. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 30423373. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.11.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。