网状Meta分析中整合研究间异质性外部证据的方法
网状Meta分析中研究间异质性方差常因数据稀疏而估计不精确,导致治疗差异标准误不稳定。本文探讨为多个异质性方差设定信息性先验的方法,包括假设异质性方差相等(方法1)、按比较类型设定不同先验(方法2)、对方差和相关性分别设先验(方法3)或使用信息性逆Wishart分布(方法4),并应用于两个网状Meta分析实例。结果表明可整合外部异质性信息而不必假设各治疗比较间异质性相等,在稀疏数据集中能提供更合适的治疗差异区间。
要点
- 外部证据可为网状Meta分析的研究间异质性方差提供信息性先验。
- 允许异质性方差不等时需确保隐含的方差-协方差矩阵有效。
- 方法在稀疏数据集中可改善治疗差异区间的合理性。
核心结论
- 相关的研究间异质性先验信息可整合进网状Meta分析,无需假设各治疗比较间异质性相等。
- 所提方法在稀疏数据集中有益,能提供比基于不精确异质性估计更合适的治疗差异区间。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,探讨网状Meta分析中多个异质性方差的信息性先验设定策略,并应用于两个网状Meta分析实例。
主要发现
- 方法1假设所有成对干预比较的异质性方差相等,对共同方差设定信息性先验较为直接。
- 方法2按干预比较类型选择不同信息性先验,并假设异质性在比较类型间成比例、类型内相等。
- 方法3对方差和相关性分别设先验,允许网络中所有异质性方差不同。
- 方法4使用信息性逆Wishart分布,允许所有异质性方差不同。
临床怎么用
- 在网状Meta分析数据稀疏、异质性方差估计不精确时,可考虑整合外部证据设定信息性先验。
- 建模时不应默认假设所有治疗比较间异质性相等,需确保方差-协方差矩阵有效。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
In a network meta-analysis, between-study heterogeneity variances are often very imprecisely estimated because data are sparse, so standard errors of treatment differences can be highly unstable. External evidence can provide informative prior distributions for heterogeneity and, hence, improve inferences. We explore approaches for specifying informative priors for multiple heterogeneity variances in a network meta-analysis. First, we assume equal heterogeneity variances across all pairwise intervention comparisons (approach 1); incorporating an informative prior for the common variance is then straightforward. Models allowing unequal heterogeneity variances are more realistic; however, care must be taken to ensure implied variance-covariance matrices remain valid. We consider three strategies for specifying informative priors for multiple unequal heterogeneity variances. Initially, we choose different informative priors according to intervention comparison type and assume heterogeneity to be proportional across comparison types and equal within comparison type (approach 2). Next, we allow all heterogeneity variances in the network to differ, while specifying a common informative prior for each. We explore two different approaches to this: placing priors on variances and correlations separately (approach 3) or using an informative inverse Wishart distribution (approach 4). Our methods are exemplified through application to two network metaanalyses. Appropriate informative priors are obtained from previously published evidence-based distributions for heterogeneity. Relevant prior information on between-study heterogeneity can be incorporated into network meta-analyses, without needing to assume equal heterogeneity across treatment comparisons. The approaches proposed will be beneficial in sparse data sets and provide more appropriate intervals for treatment differences than those based on imprecise heterogeneity estimates.
引用
- Turner RM, Domínguez-Islas CP, Jackson D, et al. Incorporating external evidence on between-trial heterogeneity in network meta-analysis. Stat Med. 2018. PMID: 30488475. doi:10.1002/sim.8044
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。