按质量分层在临床试验荟萃分析中引入选择偏倚
该研究基于一项现有荟萃分析中25种不同质量量表的分层结果进行再分析,发现质量分层本身会引入碰撞分层偏倚,导致效应量与精确度在层内产生虚假关联,从而使不同量表间结果不一致。作者认为应避免按质量分层,并展示了纳入全部研究的替代方法可获得一致结果。
要点
- 质量分层本身会引发碰撞分层偏倚,而非单纯反映方法学质量差异。
- 不同质量量表分层后效应量与显著性不一致,源于层内效应量与精确度的虚假关联。
- 建议避免按质量分层,采用纳入全部研究的替代方法以获一致结果。
核心结论
- 按质量分层会导致碰撞分层偏倚形式的选择偏倚,应避免使用。
- 纳入全部研究的替代方法可获得一致结果。
研究设计与样本
- 对一项现有荟萃分析中基于25种不同质量量表的质量亚组影响进行再分析。
主要发现
- 质量分层本身是问题所在,它会在层内诱导效应量与精确度之间的虚假关联。
- 效应量较大或精确度较低的研究往往质量较低,形成碰撞分层偏倚。
- 该关联的程度决定了以质量为条件时层间效应量和统计显著性的变异。
临床怎么用
- 在荟萃分析中避免将主要分析限制于低偏倚风险研究或按偏倚风险分层展示。
- 考虑采用纳入全部研究的替代方法以评估潜在方法学偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The inconsistency demonstrated across strata when using different scales has been attributed to quality scores, and stratification continues to be done using risk of bias domain judgments. This study examines if restricting primary meta-analyses to studies at low risk of bias or presenting meta-analyses stratified according to risk of bias is indeed the right approach to explore potential methodological bias. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Reanalysis of the impact of quality subgroupings in an existing meta-analysis based on 25 different scales. RESULTS: We demonstrate that quality stratification itself is the problem because it induces a spurious association between effect size and precision within stratum. Studies with larger effects or lesser precision tend to be of lower quality-a form of collider-stratification bias (stratum being the common effect of the reasons for these two outcomes) that leads to inconsistent results across scales. We also show that the extent of this association determines the variability in effect size and statistical significance across strata when conditioning on quality. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that stratification by quality leads to a form of selection bias (collider-stratification bias) and should be avoided. We demonstrate consistent results with an alternative method that includes all studies.
引用
- Stone J, Gurunathan U, Glass K, et al. Stratification by quality induced selection bias in a meta-analysis of clinical trials. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 30458262. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.11.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。