文献速递真实世界研究与卫生经济流行病学与生物统计

美国补充营养援助计划中食品激励与限制措施的成本效果:微观模拟研究

Cost-effectiveness of financial incentives and disincentives for improving food purchases and health through the US Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP): A microsimulation study.
PubMed 文献 · PLoS Med · 2018-10-02

本研究采用经验证的微观模拟模型,基于2009-2014年NHANES成人SNAP参与者数据,评估三种饮食干预(果蔬30%激励、果蔬激励加含糖饮料限制、多食物激励/限制组合)的健康影响与成本效果。模拟显示,三种干预均可预防心血管事件、增加QALYs并节省医疗费用;组合干预健康获益最大,从社会视角均具成本节约性。

核心结论

  • 通过SNAP促进健康饮食可产生显著健康获益,并具有成本效果或成本节约性。
  • 组合食品激励/限制方案效果最大,可能对政策制定者最具吸引力。

研究设计与样本

  • 使用经验证的微观模拟模型CVD-PREDICT,纳入2009-2014年NHANES成人SNAP参与者全国数据。

主要发现

  • 从社会视角(包括项目成本但排除食品补贴作为社会内部转移),三种情景均成本节约;概率敏感性分析中1000/1000次迭代(100%)均成本节约。

关键数值与推荐

  • 从政府可负担性视角(纳入食品补贴成本,包括未建模健康获益的儿童和年轻成人),果蔬激励5年ICER为548,053美元/QALY,终身成本效果为66,525美元/QALY。
  • 果蔬激励加含糖饮料限制10年ICER为68,857美元/QALY,20年26,435美元/QALY,终身5,216美元/QALY。

临床怎么用

  • 政策制定者可优先考虑组合食品激励/限制方案,以最大化健康获益并降低医疗和食品成本。
  • 果蔬激励加含糖饮料限制在10年即具成本效果,20年及终身非常具有成本效果。

局限性

  • 模拟研究性质决定 findings 无法证明全国性SNAP干预的实际健康和成本影响。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) provides approximately US$70 billion annually to support food purchases by low-income households, supporting approximately 1 in 7 Americans. In the 2018 Farm Bill, potential SNAP revisions to improve diets and health could include financial incentives, disincentives, or restrictions for certain foods. However, the overall and comparative impacts on health outcomes and costs are not established. We aimed to estimate the health impact, program and healthcare costs, and cost-effectiveness of food incentives, disincentives, or restrictions in SNAP. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We used a validated microsimulation model (CVD-PREDICT), populated with national data on adult SNAP participants from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) 2009-2014, policy effects from SNAP pilots and food pricing meta-analyses, diet-disease effects from meta-analyses, and policy, food, and healthcare costs from published literature to estimate the overall and comparative impacts of 3 dietary policy interventions: (1) a 30% incentive for fruits and vegetables (F&V), (2) a 30% F&V incentive with a restriction of sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs), and (3) a broader incentive/disincentive program for multiple foods that also preserves choice (SNAP-plus), combining 30% incentives for F&V, nuts, whole grains, fish, and plant-based oils and 30% disincentives for SSBs, junk food, and processed meats. Among approximately 14.5 million adults on SNAP at baseline with mean age 52 years, our simulation estimates that the F&V incentive over 5 years would prevent 38,782 cardiovascular disease (CVD) events, gain 18,928 quality-adjusted life years (QALYs), and save $1.21 billion in healthcare costs. Adding SSB restriction increased gains to 93,933 CVD events prevented, 45,864 QALYs gained, and $4.33 billion saved. For SNAP-plus, corresponding gains were 116,875 CVD events prevented, 56,056 QALYs gained, and $5.28 billion saved. Over a lifetime, the F&V incentive would prevent approximately 303,900 CVD events, gain 649,000 QALYs, and save $6.77 billion in healthcare costs. Adding SSB restriction increased gains to approximately 797,900 CVD events prevented, 2.11 million QALYs gained, and $39.16 billion in healthcare costs saved. For SNAP-plus, corresponding gains were approximately 940,000 CVD events prevented, 2.47 million QALYs gained, and $41.93 billion saved. From a societal perspective (including programmatic costs but excluding food subsidy costs as an intra-societal transfer), all 3 scenarios were cost-saving. From a government affordability perspective (i.e., incorporating food subsidy costs, including for children and young adults for whom no health gains were modeled), the F&V incentive was of low cost-effectiveness at 5 years (incremental cost-effectiveness ratio: $548,053/QALY) but achieved cost-effectiveness ($66,525/QALY) over a lifetime. Adding SSB restriction, the intervention was cost-effective at 10 years ($68,857/QALY) and very cost-effective at 20 years ($26,435/QALY) and over a lifetime ($5,216/QALY). The combined incentive/disincentive program produced the largest health gains and reduced both healthcare and food costs, with net cost-savings of $10.16 billion at 5 years and $63.33 billion over a lifetime. Results were consistent in probabilistic sensitivity analyses: for example, from a societal perspective, 1,000 of 1,000 iterations (100%) were cost-saving for all 3 interventions. Due to the nature of simulation studies, the findings cannot prove the health and cost impacts of national SNAP interventions. CONCLUSIONS: Leveraging healthier eating through SNAP could generate substantial health benefits and be cost-effective or cost-saving. A combined food incentive/disincentive program appears most effective and may be most attractive to policy-makers.

来源:PLoS Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Mozaffarian D, Liu J, Sy S, et al. Cost-effectiveness of financial incentives and disincentives for improving food purchases and health through the US Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP): A microsimulation study. PLoS Med. 2018. PMID: 30278053. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1002661

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。