中国女性、家庭成员及医务人员偏好剖宫产的比例与原因:混合方法系统综述
该系统综述纳入1990至2018年66项研究(47项定量、19项定性),评估中国大陆、香港和台湾地区女性、家庭成员及医务人员对剖宫产的偏好及原因。女性剖宫产偏好随孕周上升,纵向研究中孕早中期为14%、孕晚期为21%;定性合成显示对分娩疼痛、医患关系及照护质量的担忧促使偏好形成,医务人员偏好受经济因素和医疗诉讼恐惧影响。
要点
- 女性剖宫产偏好随孕周增加,纵向研究平均差异7%(95%CI 1%-13%)。
- 部分孕妇(4%-34%)在孕晚期仍无明确分娩方式偏好。
- 非临床因素(疼痛恐惧、医患关系、经济驱动等)共同推高剖宫产率。
核心结论
- 尽管少数女性表达剖宫产偏好,个体、卫生系统和社会文化因素共同导致中国大陆、香港和台湾地区高剖宫产率。
- 减少不必要剖宫产需针对所有非临床因素和担忧进行干预。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法系统综述,纳入1990至2018年 MEDLINE/PubMed、Embase、CINAHL、POPLINE、PsycINFO、Global Health Library 及 CNKI 的纵向、横断面和定性研究。
- 共纳入66项研究:47项定量研究和19项定性研究。
- 定量研究采用meta分析,定性研究采用meta合成。
主要发现
- 纵向研究中女性剖宫产偏好:孕早中期14%(95%CI 12%-17%),孕晚期21%(95%CI 15%-26%)。
- 横断面研究中女性剖宫产偏好:孕早中期17%(95%CI 14%-20%),孕晚期22%(95%CI 18%-25%),产后30%(95%CI 19%-40%)。
- 纵向研究显示女性剖宫产偏好随孕周上升,平均差异7%(95%CI 1%-13%)。
- 一项纵向研究报告女性伴侣的剖宫产偏好从孕晚期8%升至产后即刻17%。
- 18项定量研究显示4%至34%的孕妇即使孕晚期也无明确分娩方式偏好。
关键数值与推荐
- 定性meta合成发现女性偏好剖宫产基于优先考虑婴儿和自身健康,并在与卫生系统互动中强化。
- 女性因恐惧疼痛、与提供者关系对立及认为分娩和阴道产照护质量下降而重视绕过产程的便利,形成剖宫产最安全的感觉。
- 医务人员的剖宫产偏好受经济驱动和医疗诉讼恐惧影响。
临床怎么用
- 干预应针对女性对分娩疼痛的恐惧、医患关系及照护质量感知等非临床因素。
- 需关注医务人员的经济驱动和医疗诉讼恐惧对剖宫产决策的影响。
局限性
- 定量分析存在高异质性(尽管进行了亚组和敏感性分析)。
- 定性合成中女性剖宫产偏好可能被过度报告(部分纳入研究仅包括要求剖宫产的女性)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: China has witnessed a rapid increase of cesarean section (CS) rates in recent years. Several non-clinical factors have been cited as contributing to this trend including maternal request and perceived convenience. We aimed to assess preferences for mode of delivery and reasons for preferences for CS in China to inform the development of future interventions to mitigate unnecessary CSs, which are those performed in the absence of medical indications. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We conducted a mixed-methods systematic review and included longitudinal, cross-sectional, and qualitative studies in mainland China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan that investigated preferences for mode of delivery among women and family members and health professionals, and the reasons underlying such preferences. We searched MEDLINE/PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, POPLINE, PsycINFO, Global Health Library, and one Chinese database (CNKI) using a combination of the key terms 'caesarean section', 'preference', 'choice', 'knowledge', 'attitude', 'culture', 'non-clinical factors', and 'health professionals-patient relations' between 1990 and 2018 without language restriction. Meta-analysis of quantitative studies and meta-synthesis of qualitative studies were applied. We included 66 studies in this analysis: 47 quantitative and 19 qualitative. For the index pregnancy, the pooled proportions of preference for CS reported by women in longitudinal studies were 14% in early or middle pregnancy (95% CI 12%-17%) and 21% in late pregnancy (95% CI 15%-26%). In cross-sectional studies, the proportions were 17% in early or middle pregnancy (95% CI 14%-20%), 22% in late pregnancy (95% CI 18%-25%), and 30% postpartum (95% CI 19%-40%). Women's preferences for CS were found to rise as pregnancy progressed (preference change across longitudinal studies: mean difference 7%, 95% CI 1%-13%). One longitudinal study reported that the preference for CS among women's partners increased from 8% in late pregnancy to 17% in the immediate postpartum period. In addition, 18 quantitative studies revealed that some pregnant women, ranging from 4% to 34%, did not have a straightforward preference for a mode of delivery, even in late pregnancy. The qualitative meta-synthesis found that women's perceptions of CS as preferable were based on prioritising the baby's and woman's health and appeared to intensify through interactions with the health system. Women valued the convenience of bypassing labour because of fear of pain, antagonistic relations with providers, and beliefs of deteriorating quality of care during labour and vaginal birth, fostering the feeling that CS was the safest option. Health professionals' preference for CS was influenced by financial drivers and malpractice fears. This review has some limitations, including high heterogeneity (despite subgroup and sensitivity analysis) in the quantitative analysis, and the potential for over-reporting of women's preferences for CS in the qualitative synthesis (due to some included studies only including women who requested CS). CONCLUSIONS: Despite a minority of women expressing a preference for CS, individual, health system, and socio-cultural factors converge, contributing to a high CS rate in mainland China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan. In order to reduce unnecessary CSs, interventions need to address all these non-clinical factors and concerns. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRY: Prospero CRD42016036596.
引用
- Long Q, Kingdon C, Yang F, et al. Prevalence of and reasons for women's, family members', and health professionals' preferences for cesarean section in China: A mixed-methods systematic review. PLoS Med. 2018. PMID: 30325928. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1002672
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。