系统综述中筛选、数据提取和质量评价方法的研究证据有限
该研究旨在识别和总结评估系统综述中研究筛选、数据提取或质量评价方法的研究。通过检索MEDLINE、EMBASE和Cochrane Library(至2016年9月1日),最终纳入37项研究。结果表明,支持双人独立筛选、使用Google Translate翻译非英文文献、经验丰富的评审员参与数据提取、使用双显示器及图形数据提取软件、联系作者、强化培训和质量评价工具预试验等实践,但 documenting 常见系统综述实践的研究仍较少。
要点
- 双人独立筛选和经验丰富评审员参与可提高系统综述方法可靠性。
- 数据提取推荐双人独立、使用图形软件和双显示器,并联系作者。
- 质量评价需强化培训、预试验工具、提供决策规则,异质设计时用结构化工具。
核心结论
- 记录常见系统综述实践的研究较少,但纳入研究支持若干系统综述实践,为当前知识合成指南提供更新证据基础。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索MEDLINE、EMBASE和Cochrane Library从建库至2016年9月1日,筛选5600篇标题摘要和245篇全文后纳入37项研究。
主要发现
- 筛选方面,研究支持两名独立经验丰富评审员参与及使用Google Translate筛选非英文文章。
- 数据提取方面,研究支持经验丰富评审员参与(尤其连续结局)、两名独立评审员、双显示器、图形数据提取软件及联系作者。
- 质量评价方面,研究支持强化培训、预试验质量评价工具、为报告不佳研究提供决策规则、联系作者及纳入不同研究设计时使用结构化工具。
临床怎么用
- 系统综述筛选可采用两名独立经验丰富评审员并使用Google Translate处理非英文文献。
- 数据提取推荐两名独立评审员、双显示器、图形数据提取软件,必要时联系作者。
- 质量评价应强化培训、预试验工具、制定决策规则,异质设计时使用结构化工具。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the article was to identify and summarize studies assessing methodologies for study selection, data abstraction, or quality appraisal in systematic reviews. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A systematic review was conducted, searching MEDLINE, EMBASE, and the Cochrane Library from inception to September 1, 2016. Quality appraisal of included studies was undertaken using a modified Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies 2, and key results on accuracy, reliability, efficiency of a methodology, or impact on results and conclusions were extracted. RESULTS: After screening 5,600 titles and abstracts and 245 full-text articles, 37 studies were included. For screening, studies supported the involvement of two independent experienced reviewers and the use of Google Translate when screening non-English articles. For data abstraction, studies supported involvement of experienced reviewers (especially for continuous outcomes) and two independent reviewers, use of dual monitors, graphical data extraction software, and contacting authors. For quality appraisal, studies supported intensive training, piloting quality assessment tools, providing decision rules for poorly reported studies, contacting authors, and using structured tools if different study designs are included. CONCLUSION: Few studies exist documenting common systematic review practices. Included studies support several systematic review practices. These results provide an updated evidence-base for current knowledge synthesis guidelines and methods requiring further research.
引用
- Robson RC, Pham B, Hwee J, et al. Few studies exist examining methods for selecting studies, abstracting data, and appraising quality in a systematic review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 30312656. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.10.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。