定制荟萃分析:检验阳性率与患病率相关性的探究
定制荟萃分析(TMA)需估计适用区域,此前假设检验阳性率r与患病率p独立。本研究通过模拟比较六种估计r和p的99%置信区间方法,发现带连续性校正的Hotelling T2统计量中位覆盖概率最高(0.9971),且在不同相关性下覆盖波动最小;应用于两项已发表荟萃分析时,该方法选入研究数最多,其中一例灵敏度较其他方法提高超过4%。
要点
- 带连续性校正的Hotelling T2统计量估计r和p置信区间覆盖概率最高。
- 该方法在不同相关系数下覆盖概率波动最小,稳定性最佳。
- 应用此法定义适用区域时选入研究数最多,可提高TMA估计灵敏度。
核心结论
- TMA能提供针对实践的估计,前提是适用区域被准确定义。
- 使用带连续性校正的Hotelling T2统计量估计r和p的置信区间最可能准确定义适用区域。
研究设计与样本
- 模拟试验比较六种估计r和p的99%置信区间方法,覆盖不同相关系数、样本量及r和p取值。
- 将方法应用于两项已发表荟萃分析及其关联实践数据,评估对适用区域、选入研究和汇总估计的影响。
主要发现
- 带连续性校正的Hotelling T2统计量中位覆盖概率为0.9971,为六种方法中最高。
- 该方法和带Bonferroni校正的Clopper-Pearson法覆盖概率均持续高于0.99。
- Hotelling置信区间覆盖概率在不同相关系数下变化最小。
- 两项荟萃分析中,使用Hotelling T2统计量定义适用区域时选入研究数最多。
- 其中一例中,该方法较其他TMA方法使灵敏度提高超过4%。
关键数值与推荐
- 六种方法包括Wilson法±Bonferroni校正、Clopper-Pearson法±Bonferroni校正、Hotelling T2统计量±连续性校正。
- 带连续性校正的Hotelling T2统计量中位覆盖概率0.9971。
临床怎么用
- 在TMA中估计r和p的置信区间时,优先考虑带连续性校正的Hotelling T2统计量以准确定义适用区域。
- 适用区域可能通过常规电子健康数据获得。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Meta-analysis may produce estimates that are unrepresentative of a test's performance in practice. Tailored meta-analysis (TMA) circumvents this by deriving an applicable region for the practice and selecting the studies compatible with the region. It requires the test positive rate, r and prevalence, p being estimated for the setting but previous studies have assumed their independence. The aim is to investigate the effects a correlation between r and p has on estimating the applicable region and how this affects TMA. METHODS: Six methods for estimating 99% confidence intervals (CI) for r and p were investigated: Wilson's ± Bonferroni correction, Clopper-Pearson's ± Bonferroni correction, and Hotelling's T2 statistic ± continuity correction. These were analyzed in terms of the coverage probability using simulation trials over different correlations, sample sizes, and values for r and p. The methods were then applied to two published meta-analyses with associated practice data, and the effects on the applicable region, studies selected, and summary estimates were evaluated. RESULTS: Hotelling's T2 statistic with a continuity correction had the highest median coverage (0.9971). This and the Clopper-Pearson method with a Bonferroni correction both had coverage consistently above 0.99. The coverage of Hotelling's CI's varied the least across different correlations. For both meta-analyses, the number of studies selected was largest when Hotelling's T2 statistic was used to derive the applicable region. In one instance, this increased the sensitivity by over 4% compared with TMA estimates using other methods. CONCLUSION: TMA returns estimates that are tailored to practice providing the applicable region is accurately defined. This is most likely when the CI for r and p are estimated using Hotelling's T2 statistic with a continuity correction. Potentially, the applicable region may be obtained using routine electronic health data.
引用
- Willis BH, Coomar D, Baragilly M, et al. Tailored meta-analysis: an investigation of the correlation between the test positive rate and prevalence. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 30278213. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.09.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。