40项网状Meta分析中间接证据强度借用的实证评估
该研究对40个已发表的多治疗比较数据集同时进行网状Meta分析与成对Meta分析,用强度借用(BoS)统计量量化加入间接证据后效应估计不确定性的降低百分比,共分析915个可能治疗比较;结论是仅当至少有两项直接比较研究且治疗连接良好时,网状Meta分析才可靠提升精度。
要点
- 间接证据可减少不确定性,但增益取决于直接证据数量与网络连接性。
- 仅一项直接研究时,57.5%比较精度反而下降,12.7%无明显改善。
- 至少两项直接研究时,66.4%比较BoS≥30%,精度提升更可靠。
核心结论
- 网状Meta分析虽可能比仅基于直接证据的分析提供更精确结果,但增量增益仅在至少有两项头对头研究且治疗连接良好时可靠出现。
- 研究者应常规报告并比较网状Meta分析与成对Meta分析的结果。
研究设计与样本
- 对40个已发表的多治疗比较数据集同时进行网状Meta分析与成对Meta分析。
- 使用强度借用(BoS)统计量量化加入间接证据后效应估计不确定性的降低百分比。
- 共分析915个可能的治疗比较。
主要发现
- 915个比较中484个(53%)无直接证据,BoS=100%。
- 181个仅有一项直接研究贡献的比较中,104个(57.5%)BoS<0即精度下降,23个(12.7%)0<BoS<30%即无明显改善。
- 250个至少两项直接研究贡献的比较中,166个(66.4%)BoS≥30%即精度提升。
关键数值与推荐
- 仅一项直接研究时,57.5%比较BoS<0,12.7%比较0<BoS<30%。
- 至少两项直接研究时,66.4%比较BoS≥30%。
临床怎么用
- 在应用网状Meta分析结果前,应评估直接证据研究数量及网络连接性。
- 常规同时报告网状与成对Meta分析结果以判断精度增益的可靠性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Network meta-analysis (NMA) is increasingly being used to synthesize direct and indirect evidence and help decision makers simultaneously compare multiple treatments. We empirically evaluate the incremental gain in precision achieved by incorporating indirect evidence in NMAs. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We performed both network and pairwise meta-analyses on 40 published data sets of multiple-treatment comparisons. Their results were compared using the recently proposed borrowing of strength (BoS) statistic, which quantifies the percentage reduction in the uncertainty of the effect estimate when adding indirect evidence to an NMA. RESULTS: We analyzed 915 possible treatment comparisons, from which 484 (53%) had no direct evidence (BoS = 100%). In 181 comparisons with only one study contributing direct evidence, NMAs resulted in reduced precision (BoS < 0) and no appreciable improvements in precision (0 < BoS < 30%) for 104 (57.5%) and 23 (12.7%) comparisons, respectively. In 250 comparisons with at least two studies contributing direct evidence, NMAs provided increased precision with BoS ≥ 30% for 166 (66.4%) comparisons. CONCLUSION: Although NMAs have the potential to provide more precise results than those only based on direct evidence, the incremental gain may reliably occur only when at least two head-to-head studies are available and treatments are well connected. Researchers should routinely report and compare the results from both network and pairwise meta-analyses.
引用
- Lin L, Xing A, Kofler MJ, et al. Borrowing of strength from indirect evidence in 40 network meta-analyses. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 30342086. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.10.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。