从ClinicalTrials.gov自动提取定量数据以开展Meta分析
研究开发了基于Python的Web应用EXACT,可自动从ClinicalTrials.gov提取分析所需数据;提取准确率100%,耗时较人工从期刊文章提取减少60%;EXACT提取的数据元素87%与人工从期刊文章提取的一致;在可复现的24/28个结局中,83.3%的已发表估计值可用ClinicalTrials.gov数据复现。
要点
- EXACT自动提取数据准确率100%,耗时较人工提取期刊数据减少60%。
- EXACT提取的87%数据元素与人工从期刊文章提取的结果一致。
- 在24个可复现结局中,83.3%的已发表估计值可用ClinicalTrials.gov数据复现。
核心结论
- EXACT可自动、准确从ClinicalTrials.gov提取数据元素,减少数据提取时间。
- ClinicalTrials.gov数据复现了本研究中大多数Meta分析结果,但该结论需进一步验证。
研究设计与样本
- 开发基于Python的Web应用EXACT,自动从ClinicalTrials.gov以电子表格格式提取Meta分析所需数据。
- 确认提取数据准确性后,用这些数据重复三项已发表系统综述中的Meta分析。
- 为确保统计方法与结局一致,先用从相关期刊文章人工提取的数据重复Meta分析,再对可复现结局检验ClinicalTrials.gov数据的可用性。
主要发现
- EXACT从ClinicalTrials.gov提取数据的准确率为100%。
- EXACT提取较常规人工从期刊文章提取减少60%时间。
- EXACT提取的数据元素中87%与人工从期刊文章提取的一致。
- 用期刊文章数据可复现28个结局中的24个。
- 在这24个结局中,83.3%的已发表估计值可用ClinicalTrials.gov数据复现。
临床怎么用
- 不具备高级编程技能的用户可用EXACT从ClinicalTrials.gov自动提取分析就绪格式的数据。
- EXACT可减少Meta分析中数据提取的时间消耗。
局限性
- ClinicalTrials.gov数据复现大多数Meta分析结果的结论需进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Systematic reviews and meta-analyses are labor-intensive and time-consuming. Automated extraction of quantitative data from primary studies can accelerate this process. ClinicalTrials.gov, launched in 2000, is the world's largest trial repository of results data from clinical trials; it has been used as a source instead of journal articles. We have developed a Web application called EXACT (EXtracting Accurate efficacy and safety information from ClinicalTrials.gov) that allows users without advanced programming skills to automatically extract data from ClinicalTrials.gov in analysis-ready format. We have also used the automatically extracted data to examine the reproducibility of meta-analyses in three published systematic reviews. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We developed a Python-based software application (EXACT) that automatically extracts data required for meta-analysis from the ClinicalTrials.gov database in a spreadsheet format. We confirmed the accuracy of the extracted data and then used those data to repeat meta-analyses in three published systematic reviews. To ensure that we used the same statistical methods and outcomes as the published systematic reviews, we repeated the meta-analyses using data manually extracted from the relevant journal articles. For the outcomes whose results we were able to reproduce using those journal article data, we examined the usability of ClinicalTrials.gov data. RESULTS: EXACT extracted data at ClincalTrials.gov with 100% accuracy, and it required 60% less time than the usual practice of manually extracting data from journal articles. We found that 87% of the data elements extracted using EXACT matched those extracted manually from the journal articles. We were able to reproduce 24 of 28 outcomes using the journal article data. Of these 24 outcomes, we were able to reproduce 83.3% of the published estimates using data at ClinicalTrials.gov. CONCLUSION: EXACT (http://bio-nlp.org/EXACT) automatically and accurately extracted data elements from ClinicalTrials.gov and thus reduced time in data extraction. The ClinicalTrials.gov data reproduced most meta-analysis results in our study, but this conclusion needs further validation.
引用
- Pradhan R, Hoaglin DC, Cornell M, et al. Automatic extraction of quantitative data from ClinicalTrials.gov to conduct meta-analyses. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 30257185. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.08.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。