随机效应荟萃分析在新临床试验设计与分析中的应用
本文讨论了在随机对照试验设计中利用现有证据的两种方法:基于荟萃分析构建先验分布进行贝叶斯功效分析,或计算试验对更新荟萃分析合并估计的影响。作者指出当存在异质性时,随机效应均值很少代表试验者目标参数,建议使用预测分布或最相似研究的收缩估计。
要点
- 随机效应均值通常不是试验者目标参数,不宜作为功效计算基础。
- 异质性来源的信念影响先验分布选择和新试验预期功效。
- 无解释异质性时,建议以荟萃分析的预测分布作为先验基础。
核心结论
- 随机效应均值很少代表试验者目标参数,基于其进行功效计算或作为先验分布通常不合适。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为方法学论述,未报告具体研究设计与样本量。
主要发现
- 基于随机效应均值的贝叶斯功效分析与基于更新荟萃分析合并估计的功效分析在存在异质性时结果可能差异很大。
- 对异质性来源的信念会影响先前证据的使用方式,并深刻影响新试验的预期功效。
关键数值与推荐
- 更合适的替代方法包括预测分布和最相似研究的收缩估计。
- 考虑试验对整个随机效应分布的影响有时可能是合适的。
临床怎么用
- 设计新试验时应仔细考虑现有研究间异质性的可能原因。
- 缺乏异质性解释时,建议使用荟萃分析的预测分布作为干预效应先验分布的基础。
局限性
- 原文未报告具体研究设计与样本量等局限性信息。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
In designing a randomized controlled trial, it has been argued that trialists should consider existing evidence about the likely intervention effect. One approach is to form a prior distribution for the intervention effect based on a meta-analysis of previous studies and then power the trial on its ability to affect the posterior distribution in a Bayesian analysis. Alternatively, methods have been proposed to calculate the power of the trial to influence the "pooled" estimate in an updated meta-analysis. These two approaches can give very different results if the existing evidence is heterogeneous, summarised using a random effects meta-analysis. We argue that the random effects mean will rarely represent the trialist's target parameter, and so, it will rarely be appropriate to power a trial based on its impact upon the random effects mean. Furthermore, the random effects mean will not generally provide an appropriate prior distribution. More appropriate alternatives include the predictive distribution and shrinkage estimate for the most similar study. Consideration of the impact of the trial on the entire random effects distribution might sometimes be appropriate. We describe how beliefs about likely sources of heterogeneity have implications for how the previous evidence should be used and can have a profound impact on the expected power of the new trial. We conclude that the likely causes of heterogeneity among existing studies need careful consideration. In the absence of explanations for heterogeneity, we suggest using the predictive distribution from the meta-analysis as the basis for a prior distribution for the intervention effect.
引用
- Jones HE, Ades AE, Sutton AJ, et al. Use of a random effects meta-analysis in the design and analysis of a new clinical trial. Stat Med. 2018. PMID: 30187505. doi:10.1002/sim.7948
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。