将高危登记册整合入英国基层医疗以预防哮喘危机(ARRISA-UK):实用性整群随机试验研究方案
ARRISA-UK是一项实用性、双臂、多中心整群随机对照试验,辅以卫生经济学与过程评价,计划在英国随机分配270家基层医疗诊所,覆盖逾1万名按经验证算法识别的「高危哮喘」注册患者。干预组诊所员工完成两个45分钟电子学习模块及30分钟网络研讨会,患者病历被标记并在就诊时提示,诊所于4周、6周和6个月分别接受电话与提醒视频;对照组维持常规照护。主要结局为12个月后发生哮喘相关危机事件(急诊就诊、住院和死亡)的高危患者百分比。
要点
- 主要结局为12个月时发生哮喘相关危机事件的高危患者百分比。
- 干预包括员工电子学习、病历标记提示及多次提醒。
- 研究同时开展成本效果分析与混合方法过程评价。
核心结论
- 该方案旨在确定ARRISA干预在减少哮喘相关危机事件方面的有效性与成本效果。
研究设计与样本
- 实用性、双臂、多中心、整群随机对照试验,辅以卫生经济学与过程评价;计划随机分配英国270家基层医疗诊所,覆盖逾1万名高危哮喘注册患者;试验注册号ISRCTN95472706,注册日期2014年12月5日。
主要发现
- 此前对干预(ARRISA)的二次分析提示基层医疗中高危哮喘患者管理有所改善;本试验尚处方案阶段,未报告结局数据。
关键数值与推荐
- 高危哮喘患者按经验证算法识别;干预组员工完成两个45分钟电子学习模块(个人完成的背景模块与小组完成的诊所范围照护路径模块)及30分钟网络研讨会;培训完成后高危患者病历被编码,记录被访问时显示标记;4周电话、6周与6个月提醒视频;主要结局为12个月后哮喘相关危机事件(急诊就诊、住院和死亡)的高危患者百分比;同时采集危机事件时间、全因住院、哮喘控制及诊所哮喘管理变化。
临床怎么用
- 在基层医疗中识别高危哮喘患者、标记电子病历并培训员工建立诊所范围照护流程,并配合提醒,可能有助于减少哮喘危机事件。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Despite effective treatments and long-standing management guidelines, there are approximately 1400 hospital admissions for asthma weekly in the United Kingdom (UK), many of which could be avoided. In our previous research, a secondary analysis of the intervention (ARRISA) suggested an improvement in the management of at-risk asthma patients in primary care. ARRISA involved identifying individuals at risk of adverse asthma events, flagging their electronic health records, training practice staff to develop and implement practice-wide processes of care when alerted by the flag, plus motivational reminders. We now seek to determine the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of ARRISA in reducing asthma-related crisis events. METHODS: We are undertaking a pragmatic, two-arm, multicentre, cluster randomised controlled trial, plus health economic and process evaluation. We will randomise 270 primary care practices from throughout the UK covering over 10,000 registered patients with 'at-risk asthma' identified according to a validated algorithm. Staff in practices randomised to the intervention will complete two 45-min eLearning modules (an individually completed module giving background to ARRISA and a group-completed module to develop practice-wide pathways of care) plus a 30-min webinar with other practices. On completion of training at-risk patients' records will be coded so that a flag appears whenever their record is accessed. Practices will receive a phone call at 4 weeks and a reminder video at 6 weeks and 6 months. Control practices will continue to provide usual care. We will extract anonymised routine patient data from primary care records (with linkage to secondary care data) to determine the percentage of at-risk patients with an asthma-related crisis event (accident and emergency attendances, hospitalisations and deaths) after 12 months (primary outcome). We will also capture the time to crisis event, all-cause hospitalisations, asthma control and any changes in practice asthma management for at-risk and all patients with asthma. Cost-effectiveness analysis and mixed-methods process evaluations will also be conducted. DISCUSSION: This study is novel in terms of using a practice-wide intervention to target and engage with patients at risk from their asthma and is innovative in the use of routinely captured data with record linkage to obtain trial outcomes. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ISRCTN95472706 . Registered on 5 December 2014.
引用
- Smith JR, Musgrave S, Payerne E, et al. At-risk registers integrated into primary care to stop asthma crises in the UK (ARRISA-UK): study protocol for a pragmatic, cluster randomised trial with nested health economic and process evaluations. Trials. 2018. PMID: 30157917. doi:10.1186/s13063-018-2816-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。