中低收入国家整群随机试验中干预保真度评估的注册与发表比较:系统综述
该系统综述纳入2012年1月至2016年5月发表的90项在中低收入国家开展的公共卫生干预整群随机试验,比较试验注册方案与发表报告中干预保真度(IF)评估的计划与报告情况。结果显示28%的研究未计划或报告评估IF,方案中计划评估IF的比例为40%,发表报告中报告评估IF的比例为71.1%,方案与报告关于是否评估IF的一致比例为66.7%。结论认为IF评估在中低收入国家整群随机试验中尚未成为系统实践。
要点
- 中低收入国家公共卫生整群随机试验中,28%未计划或报告评估干预保真度。
- 试验方案中计划评估保真度的比例为40%,发表报告中报告评估的比例为71.1%。
- 方案与报告关于是否评估保真度的一致比例为66.7%,提示报告存在不一致。
核心结论
- 干预保真度评估在中低收入国家公共卫生干预整群随机试验中尚未成为系统实践。
- 缺乏保真度评估时,难以判断试验结果源于干预设计、实施过程还是未知或外部因素。
- 整群随机试验报告指南应促进干预保真度评估。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述纳入在中低收入国家开展的公共卫生干预整群随机试验,要求试验方案或主要报告计划或报告了干预保真度评估。
- 检索MEDLINE/PubMed、CINAHL和EMBASE数据库2012年1月至2016年5月的文献,仅纳入摘要中报告注册号的试验。
- 共纳入90项有公开试验注册方案的中低收入国家公共卫生干预整群随机试验。
- 由两名研究者使用预定义筛选表从每项研究的方案和试验报告中提取数据,并评估个体研究的偏倚风险。
主要发现
- 90项研究中,25项(28%)未计划或报告评估干预保真度,其余65项(72%)涉及至少一个保真度维度。
- 干预保真度评估在40%(36/90)的试验方案中有计划,在71.1%(64/90)的试验报告中有报告。
- 试验方案与试验报告关于是否评估干预保真度的一致比例为66.7%(60/90)。
- 多数研究偏倚风险为低至中等。
临床怎么用
- 在中低收入国家开展公共卫生干预整群随机试验时,应在方案中计划并在报告中系统评估干预保真度。
- 解读整群随机试验结果时,需考虑是否进行了保真度评估以判断效应来源。
局限性
- 仅纳入摘要中报告注册号且有公开试验方案的整群随机试验,可能遗漏未注册或方案不可得的研究。
- 检索时间范围为2012年1月至2016年5月,未涵盖此后发表的研究。
- 未报告干预保真度评估的具体工具或方法的标准化比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Cluster randomised trials (CRTs) are a key instrument to evaluate public health interventions. Fidelity assessment examines study processes to gauge whether an intervention was delivered as initially planned. Evaluation of implementation fidelity (IF) is required to establish whether the measured effects of a trial are due to the intervention itself and may be particularly important for CRTs of complex interventions conducted in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). However, current CRT reporting guidelines offer no guidance on IF assessment. The objective of this review was to study current practices concerning the assessment of IF in CRTs of public health interventions in LMICs. METHODS: CRTs of public health interventions in LMICs that planned or reported IF assessment in either the trial protocol or the main trial report were included. The MEDLINE/PubMed, CINAHL and EMBASE databases were queried from January 2012 to May 2016. To ensure availability of a study protocol, CRTs reporting a registration number in the abstract were included. Relevant data were extracted from each study protocol and trial report by two researchers using a predefined screening sheet. Risk of bias for individual studies was assessed. RESULTS: We identified 90 CRTs of public health interventions in LMICs with a study protocol in a publicly available trial registry published from January 2012 to May 2016. Among these 90 studies, 25 (28%) did not plan or report assessing IF; the remaining 65 studies (72%) addressed at least one IF dimension. IF assessment was planned in 40% (36/90) of trial protocols and reported in 71.1% (64/90) of trial reports. The proportion of overall agreement between the trial protocol and trial report concerning occurrence of IF assessment was 66.7% (60/90). Most studies had low to moderate risk of bias. CONCLUSIONS: IF assessment is not currently a systematic practice in CRTs of public health interventions carried out in LMICs. In the absence of IF assessment, it may be difficult to determine if CRT results are due to the intervention design, to its implementation, or to unknown or external factors that may influence results. CRT reporting guidelines should promote IF assessment. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Protocol published and available at: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13643-016-0351-0.
引用
- Pérez MC, Minoyan N, Ridde V, et al. Comparison of registered and published intervention fidelity assessment in cluster randomised trials of public health interventions in low- and middle-income countries: systematic review. Trials. 2018. PMID: 30064484. doi:10.1186/s13063-018-2796-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。