争议与辩论:基于记忆的膳食评估方法的致命缺陷
本文针对食物频率问卷等基于记忆的膳食评估方法展开辩论。作者认为这些方法在科学研究和循证政策制定中无效且不可接受,并提出五方面论证:逻辑谬误、记忆不可靠、测量误差不可证伪、伪定量化违背测量理论、代理估计生理上不合理。
要点
- 基于记忆的膳食评估方法存在类别错误与具体化谬误。
- 自报膳食数据的测量误差在流行病学中不可证伪。
- 将营养素值赋予自报摄入的伪定量化违反测量理论。
核心结论
- 基于记忆的膳食评估方法在科学研究和循证政策制定中无效且不可接受。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为立场性辩论文章,未报告系统检索或样本量。
主要发现
- 基于记忆的方法 founded upon 类别错误与具体化两个逻辑谬误。
- 人类记忆与回忆不是科学数据收集的有效工具。
- 自报数据的测量误差在标准流行病学背景下不可证伪。
- 将营养素和能量值赋予自报摄入的伪定量化不允许且违反测量理论基本原则。
- 伪定量化产生的代理估计常生理上不合理,与实际营养素和能量摄入关系甚微。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
There is an escalating debate over the value and validity of self-reported dietary intake as estimated by Food Frequency Questionnaires and other forms of memory-based dietary assessment methods. Proponents argue that despite limitations, memory-based methods provide valid and valuable information about consumed foods and beverages and therefore can be used to assess diet-disease relations. In fact, over the past 60 years, thousands of memory-based dietary research reports were used to inform public policy and establish the Dietary Guidelines for Americans. Yet, despite this impressive history, our position is that memory-based dietary assessment methods are invalid and inadmissible for scientific research and therefore cannot be used in evidence-based policy making. Herein, we present the empirical evidence and theoretic and philosophic perspectives that render data derived from memory-based methods both fatally flawed and pseudoscientific. First, the use of memory-based methods is founded upon two inter-related logical fallacies: a category error and reification. Second, human memory and recall are not valid instruments for scientific data collection. Third, in standard epidemiologic contexts, the measurement errors associated with self-reported data are nonfalsifiable because there is no way to ascertain if the reported foods and beverages match the respondent's actual consumption. Fourth, the assignment of nutrient and energy values to self-reported intake (i.e., the pseudoquantification of anecdotal data) is impermissible and violates the foundational tenets of measurement theory. Fifth, the proxy estimates created via pseudoquantification are often physiologically implausible and have little relation to actual nutrient and energy consumption. Finally, investigators engendered a fictional discourse on the health effects of dietary sugar, salt, fat and cholesterol when they failed to cite contrary evidence or address decades of research demonstrating the fatal measurement, analytic, and inferential flaws of memory-based dietary assessment methods.
引用
- Archer E, Marlow ML, Lavie CJ, et al. Controversy and debate: Memory-Based Methods Paper 1: the fatal flaws of food frequency questionnaires and other memory-based dietary assessment methods. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 30121379. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.08.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。