连续结局个体参与者数据荟萃分析:一阶段模型设定与估计方法比较
该研究通过广泛模拟评估个体参与者数据荟萃分析中分层截距与随机截距一阶段模型对汇总治疗效应估计的影响,并比较最大似然与限制最大似然估计及不同置信区间推导方法。结果显示在1:1分配和效应异质性下,限制最大似然下两模型偏倚与覆盖率相似,Kenward-Roger或Satterthwaite校正通常最佳,若必须用最大似然则随机截距更优。
要点
- 限制最大似然下分层与随机截距模型偏倚和覆盖率相似,均可选用。
- 置信区间推荐Kenward-Roger或Satterthwaite校正,但偶有过保守。
- 若需最大似然估计,随机截距模型优于分层截距模型。
核心结论
- 在1:1治疗对照分配且存在治疗效应异质性时,限制最大似然下分层与随机截距模型对汇总治疗效应估计的偏倚和覆盖率非常相似。
- 置信区间通常最好采用Kenward-Roger或Satterthwaite校正,尽管偶尔过于保守。
- 若必须使用最大似然,随机截距模型的表现优于分层截距模型。
研究设计与样本
- 针对连续结局的一阶段个体参与者数据荟萃分析模型开展广泛模拟研究。
- 比较分层截距与随机截距两种模型设定。
- 比较最大似然与限制最大似然两种估计方法。
- 比较标准正态95%CI、Kenward-Roger和Satterthwaite三种置信区间推导方法。
- 提供一个说明性示例。
主要发现
- 在1:1治疗对照分配且治疗效应存在异质性时,限制最大似然下分层与随机截距模型的偏倚和覆盖率非常相似。
- Kenward-Roger或Satterthwaite校正通常能最好地推导置信区间,但偶尔过于保守。
- 若需要最大似然估计,随机截距模型比分层截距模型表现更好。
临床怎么用
- 实践中可采用分层截距或随机截距模型配合限制最大似然进行一阶段个体参与者数据荟萃分析。
- 优先使用Kenward-Roger或Satterthwaite校正推导汇总治疗效应的置信区间。
- 当必须使用最大似然估计时,选择随机截距模型而非分层截距模型。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
One-stage individual participant data meta-analysis models should account for within-trial clustering, but it is currently debated how to do this. For continuous outcomes modeled using a linear regression framework, two competing approaches are a stratified intercept or a random intercept. The stratified approach involves estimating a separate intercept term for each trial, whereas the random intercept approach assumes that trial intercepts are drawn from a normal distribution. Here, through an extensive simulation study for continuous outcomes, we evaluate the impact of using the stratified and random intercept approaches on statistical properties of the summary treatment effect estimate. Further aims are to compare (i) competing estimation options for the one-stage models, including maximum likelihood and restricted maximum likelihood, and (ii) competing options for deriving confidence intervals (CI) for the summary treatment effect, including the standard normal-based 95% CI, and more conservative approaches of Kenward-Roger and Satterthwaite, which inflate CIs to account for uncertainty in variance estimates. The findings reveal that, for an individual participant data meta-analysis of randomized trials with a 1:1 treatment:control allocation ratio and heterogeneity in the treatment effect, (i) bias and coverage of the summary treatment effect estimate are very similar when using stratified or random intercept models with restricted maximum likelihood, and thus either approach could be taken in practice, (ii) CIs are generally best derived using either a Kenward-Roger or Satterthwaite correction, although occasionally overly conservative, and (iii) if maximum likelihood is required, a random intercept performs better than a stratified intercept model. An illustrative example is provided.
引用
- Legha A, Riley RD, Ensor J, et al. Individual participant data meta-analysis of continuous outcomes: A comparison of approaches for specifying and estimating one-stage models. Stat Med. 2018. PMID: 30101507. doi:10.1002/sim.7930
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。