美国相关系统评价与meta分析检索资源多样性不足:2005-2016
该研究手动审查2005-2016年每年随机抽取的100篇美国相关系统评价与meta分析(SRMA),分析检索资源趋势及与发表偏倚的关联。817篇纳入文章中,Medline(95%)、EMBASE(44%)和Cochrane(41%)最常用;2013年检索指南未显著增加注册库和灰色文献检索。在Medline基础上补充检索Scopus(所有SRMA)和ClinicalTrials.gov(有安全性结局的SRMA)与发表偏倚呈负相关。
要点
- 多数SRMA仅检索Medline等已发表文献资源,注册库和灰色文献检索不足。
- 2013年检索指南未显著改善注册库和灰色文献的检索情况。
- 在Medline基础上补充Scopus和ClinicalTrials.gov可能降低发表偏倚风险。
核心结论
- 即使检索多个来源的SRMA也倾向于检索相似资源,补充检索Scopus和ClinicalTrials.gov可减少发表偏倚机会。
研究设计与样本
- 研究手动审查2005-2016年每年随机抽取的100篇美国相关SRMA,最终纳入817篇,分析检索数据库相关因素、网络共检索模式及与发表偏倚的关联。
主要发现
- 817篇SRMA中常用资源为Medline(95%)、EMBASE(44%)和Cochrane(41%)。
- 方法学杂志的SRMA最可能使用注册库和灰色文献资源。
- 存在大量仅检索已发表材料的共检索,未补充注册库和灰色文献检索。
- 2013年指南未显著增加检索注册库和灰色文献以获取原始研究。
- 补充检索Scopus(所有SRMA)和ClinicalTrials.gov(有安全性结局的SRMA)与发表偏倚呈负相关。
临床怎么用
- 在Medline基础上补充检索Scopus和ClinicalTrials.gov,以降低发表偏倚风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Systematic reviews and meta-analyses (SRMAs) rely upon comprehensive searches into diverse resources that catalog primary studies. However, since what constitutes a comprehensive search is unclear, we examined trends in databases searched from 2005-2016, surrounding the publication of search guidelines in 2013, and associations between resources searched and evidence of publication bias in SRMAs involving human subjects. STUDY DESIGN: To ensure comparability of included SRMAs over the 12 years in the face of a near 100-fold increase of international SRMAs (mainly genetic studies from China) during this period, we focused on USA-affiliated SRMAs, manually reviewing 100 randomly selected SRMAs from those published in each year. After excluding articles (mainly for inadequate detail or out-of-scope methods), we identified factors associated with the databases searched, used network analysis to see which resources were simultaneously searched, and used logistic regression to link information sources searched with a lower chance of finding publication bias. RESULTS: Among 817 SRMA articles studied, the common resources used were Medline (95%), EMBASE (44%), and Cochrane (41%). Methods journal SRMAs were most likely to use registries and grey literature resources. We found substantial co-searching of resources with only published materials, and not complemented by searches of registries and the grey literature. The 2013 guideline did not substantially increase searching of registries and grey literature resources to retrieve primary studies for the SRMAs. When used to augment Medline, Scopus (in all SRMAs) and ClinicalTrials.gov (in SRMAs with safety outcomes) were negatively associated with publication bias. CONCLUSIONS: Even SRMAs that search multiple sources tend to search similar resources. Our study supports searching Scopus and CTG in addition to Medline to reduce the chance of publication bias.
引用
- Pradhan R, Garnick K, Barkondaj B, et al. Inadequate diversity of information resources searched in US-affiliated systematic reviews and meta-analyses: 2005-2016. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 29879464. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.05.024
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。