文献速递流行病学与生物统计

三种偏倚风险工具在观察性研究合成中得出相反结论

Three risk of bias tools lead to opposite conclusions in observational research synthesis.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2018-06-02

该研究在一项健康心理学Meta分析纳入的28项比较性队列研究中,同时应用纽卡斯尔-渥太华量表、队列研究质量工具(Q-Coh)和非随机干预研究偏倚风险工具(ROBINS-I)评估偏倚风险。结果显示不同工具评分者间一致性差异很大,总体偏倚风险判读结论相反;三种工具的质量评级均未对Meta分析结果产生影响。

要点

  • 三种偏倚风险工具对同一批队列研究的总体偏倚风险判读可得出相反结论。
  • 基于领域的工具(Q-Coh、ROBINS-I)能更全面识别潜在偏倚来源。
  • 需加强偏倚风险工具应用指导并改善原始研究报告质量。

核心结论

  • 使用三种工具评估偏倚风险可能得出相反结论,尤其在低和高偏倚风险水平上。
  • 基于领域的工具(Q-Coh和ROBINS-I)提供了更全面的框架来识别潜在偏倚来源。
  • 需要进一步指导偏倚风险工具的应用,并改进原始研究的报告。

研究设计与样本

  • 对选定的健康心理学Meta分析中纳入的28项原始研究应用三种偏倚风险工具。
  • 三种工具分别为纽卡斯尔-渥太华量表、队列研究质量工具(Q-Coh)和非随机干预研究偏倚风险工具(ROBINS-I)。

主要发现

  • 评分者间一致性因工具不同而差异很大。
  • 总体偏倚风险方面,纽卡斯尔-渥太华量表将75%的研究评为低偏倚风险。
  • Q-Coh将11%的研究评为低偏倚风险。
  • ROBINS-I未发现任何研究为低偏倚风险。
  • 未发现任何工具的质量评级对Meta分析结果产生影响。

临床怎么用

  • 在观察性研究合成中应谨慎选择偏倚风险工具,并注意不同工具可能给出相反结论。
  • 可优先考虑基于领域的工具以更全面识别潜在偏倚来源。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to assess the agreement and compare the performance of three different instruments in assessing risk of bias (RoB) of comparative cohort studies included in a health psychology meta-analysis. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Three tools were applied to 28 primary studies included in the selected meta-analysis: the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale, quality of cohort studies (Q-Coh), and risk of bias in nonrandomized studies of interventions (ROBINS-I). RESULTS: Interrater agreement varied greatly from tool to tool. For overall RoB, 75% of the studies were rated as low RoB with the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale, 11% of the studies with Q-Coh, and no study was found to be at low RoB using ROBINS-I. No influence of quality ratings on the meta-analysis results was found for any of the tools. CONCLUSION: Assessing RoB using the three tools may lead to opposite conclusions, especially at low and high levels of RoB. Domain-based tools (Q-Coh and ROBINS-I) provide a more comprehensive framework for identifying potential sources of bias, which is essential to improving the quality of future research. Both further guidance on the application of RoB tools and improvements in the reporting of primary studies are necessary.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Losilla JM, Oliveras I, Marin-Garcia JA, et al. Three risk of bias tools lead to opposite conclusions in observational research synthesis. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 29864541. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.05.021

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。