多变量网络Meta分析减轻结局报告偏倚的影响
结局报告偏倚(ORB)威胁配对与网络Meta分析的有效性,多变量方法在配对场景下可减少偏倚。本研究通过广泛的贝叶斯多变量网络Meta分析(MNMA)模拟,评估其能否在随机缺失与非随机缺失等多种结局缺失场景下减少ORB对合并效应量的影响,并应用于老年抑郁症抗抑郁药多治疗系统评价。
要点
- MNMA在多种结局缺失场景下可减少合并效应量的偏倚。
- MNMA提高估计精度,产生更窄的可信区间。
- MNMA需建模治疗与结局间相关性,协方差矩阵维度随治疗与结局数快速增长。
核心结论
- 贝叶斯MNMA在随机缺失与非随机缺失等多种结局缺失场景下减少合并效应量的偏倚并提高精度。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为贝叶斯多变量网络Meta分析的广泛模拟研究,并应用于老年抑郁症抗抑郁药随机对照试验的多治疗系统评价。
主要发现
- MNMA在多种结局缺失场景下减少合并效应量的偏倚,包括随机缺失与非随机缺失。
- MNMA提高估计精度,产生更窄的可信区间。
临床怎么用
- 在多治疗系统评价中可采用MNMA以减轻ORB对合并效应量的影响并提高估计精度。
局限性
- MNMA实施具挑战性,因需建模治疗与结局间相关性,协方差矩阵维度与待估成分数随治疗数和结局数快速增长。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Outcome reporting bias (ORB) is recognized as a threat to the validity of both pairwise and network meta-analysis (NMA). In recent years, multivariate meta-analytic methods have been proposed to reduce the impact of ORB in the pairwise setting. These methods have shown that multivariate meta-analysis can reduce bias and increase efficiency of pooled effect sizes. However, it is unknown whether multivariate NMA (MNMA) can similarly reduce the impact of ORB. Additionally, it is quite challenging to implement MNMA due to the fact that correlation between treatments and outcomes must be modeled; thus, the dimension of the covariance matrix and number of components to estimate grows quickly with the number of treatments and number of outcomes. To determine whether MNMA can reduce the effects of ORB on pooled treatment effect sizes, we present an extensive simulation study of Bayesian MNMA. Via simulation studies, we show that MNMA reduces the bias of pooled effect sizes under a variety of outcome missingness scenarios, including missing at random and missing not at random. Further, MNMA improves the precision of estimates, producing narrower credible intervals. We demonstrate the applicability of the approach via application of MNMA to a multi-treatment systematic review of randomized controlled trials of anti-depressants for the treatment of depression in older adults.
引用
- Hwang H, DeSantis SM. Multivariate network meta-analysis to mitigate the effects of outcome reporting bias. Stat Med. 2018. PMID: 29882392. doi:10.1002/sim.7815
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。