经皮电刺激、手针与电针治疗耳鸣效果比较:随机对照试验方案
主要结局为第1次至第10次访视间耳鸣残疾量表(THI)评分变化,次要结局包括THI应答率、耳鸣响度与烦恼视觉模拟评分、纯音测听与言语识别及心率变异性参数变化。研究旨在比较三种疗法 Effects 与安全性,为耳鸣临床治疗选择提供依据。
要点
- 主要结局为10次治疗前后THI评分变化,次要结局含VAS、听力学与心率变异性。
- TENS取咬肌与胸锁乳突肌压痛点、耳屏前及乳突部四个部位刺激。
核心结论
- 三种疗法对耳鸣的比较疗效此前尚未确定,本试验旨在比较TENS、手针与电针的效果与安全性。
- 若某一疗法较其他疗法显示显著效果,可能作为耳鸣的初级治疗用于临床实践。
研究设计与样本
- TENS组在四个部位治疗;手针组取患侧及双侧共11个穴位;电针组在手针取穴基础上加电刺激。
- 每组治疗10次、每周2次;主要结局为第1次至第10次访视间THI评分变化。
主要发现
- 本稿为试验方案,未报告疗效结果。
- 背景指出TENS因安全便捷而广泛使用并用于耳鸣数十年,针刺可通过刺激躯体感觉系统改善某类耳鸣,电针为针刺与电刺激结合。
- 次要结局包括THI应答率、耳鸣响度与烦恼VAS变化、纯音测听与言语识别及心率变异性参数变化。
关键数值与推荐
- TENS组治疗部位:咬肌与胸锁乳突肌压痛点、耳屏前、乳突部,共四处。
- 手针组取穴:患侧TE21、SI19、GB2、TE22、ST7、TE17、GB20,双侧GB20、TE05、KI3,共11穴。
- 电针组在TE21、SI19、TE17、GB20加电刺激。
- 主要结局为第1次至第10次访视间THI评分变化。
临床怎么用
- 研究结果可为耳鸣选择TENS、手针或电针作为初级治疗提供比较依据;当前方案阶段尚不能给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 试验为非盲设计。
- 试验注册为回顾性注册(KCT0002117,2016年10月21日)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) involves a neuromodulatory effect using electrical stimulation and has been widely used due to its safety and convenience. It has been used for treating tinnitus for decades. Acupuncture has also been used for tinnitus and several research studies have shown that acupuncture can improve a certain kind of tinnitus by stimulating the somatosensory system. Moreover, several studies have shown the efficacy of electroacupuncture, which is a combination of acupuncture and electrical stimulation, for tinnitus. However, the comparative effectiveness of TENS, manual acupuncture, and electroacupuncture for the treatment of tinnitus has not been determined previously. Herein, we design a randomized, non-blind clinical trial to investigate and compare the effects and safety of TENS, manual acupuncture, and electroacupuncture for tinnitus. METHODS: After screening, 45 patients are randomly assigned to three groups: (1) patients in the TENS group are treated at four sites (tender points of masseter and the sternocleidomastoid muscle, in front of tragus, and mastoid process); (2) the manual acupuncture group patients are treated at 11 acupoints (TE21, SI19, GB2, TE22, ST7, TE17, GB20 of tinnitus affected side, and GB20, TE05, KI3 of both sides); (3) electroacupuncture group patients are treated by using acupuncture as in the manual acupuncture group and electrical stimulation at TE21, SI19, TE17, and GB20. Patients are treated for ten sessions, twice a week. The primary outcome measurement is the change of Tinnitus Handicap Inventory (THI) score between visit 1 and visit 10. The secondary outcome measurements are the response rate of THI, change in visual analogue scale associated with the loudness and annoyance of tinnitus, pure-tone audiometry and speech discrimination, and changes in parameters of heart rate variability. DISCUSSION: The purpose of this study is to compare the effect of TENS, manual acupuncture, and electroacupuncture in the auricular area on tinnitus. If the specific treatment shows a significant effect compared to other treatments, it could have potential for use in clinical practice as a primary treatment. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Clinical Research Information Service (CRIS), KCT0002117 . Registered October 21, 2016. Retrospectively registered.
引用
- Moon YK, Kim MH, Nam HJ, et al. Comparison of the effectiveness between transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, manual acupuncture, and electroacupuncture on tinnitus: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Trials. 2018. PMID: 29945669. doi:10.1186/s13063-018-2738-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。