已发表临床试验方案中统计分析方法的预先设定不足
99个合格方案中,仅少数充分设定分析人群(8/99,8%)、分析模型(27/99,27%)、协变量使用(40/99,40%)或缺失数据处理方法(10/99,10%)。多数方案未充分预先定义任何方面(39%)或仅定义一方面(36%),无方案充分预定义全部四方面。
要点
- 已发表试验方案中主要结局统计分析方法预先设定普遍不足。
- 分析人群和缺失数据处理方法的预先设定比例最低(分别为8%和10%)。
- 无方案充分预定义分析人群、模型、协变量和缺失数据处理全部四方面。
核心结论
- 已发表临床试验方案中统计分析方法很少被预先设定,可能允许基于不同分析的选择性报告。
主要发现
- 充分预先设定分析人群的方案为8/99(8%)。
- 充分预先设定分析模型的方案为27/99(27%)。
- 充分预先设定协变量使用的方案为40/99(40%)。
- 充分预先设定缺失数据处理方法的方案为10/99(10%)。
- 多数方案未充分预定义任何四方面(39%)或仅预定义一方面(36%),无方案充分预定义全部四方面。
临床怎么用
- 试验方案应充分预先设定主要结局的分析人群、分析模型、协变量使用和缺失数据处理方法,以减少选择性报告偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Results from randomized trials can depend on the statistical analysis approach used. It is important to prespecify the analysis approach in the trial protocol to avoid selective reporting of analyses based on those which provide the most favourable results. We undertook a review of published trial protocols to assess how often the statistical analysis of the primary outcome was adequately prespecified. METHODS: We searched protocols of randomized trials indexed in PubMed in November 2016. We identified whether the following aspects of the statistical analysis approach for the primary outcome were adequately prespecified: (1) analysis population; (2) analysis model; (3) use of covariates; and (4) method of handling missing data. RESULTS: We identified 99 eligible protocols. Very few protocols adequately prespecified the analysis population (8/99, 8%), analysis model (27/99, 27%), covariates (40/99, 40%), or approach to handling missing data (10/99, 10%). Most protocols did not adequately predefine any of these four aspects of their statistical analysis approach (39%) or predefined only one aspect (36%). No protocols adequately predefined all four aspects of the analysis. CONCLUSION: The statistical analysis approach is rarely prespecified in published trial protocols. This may allow selective reporting of results based on different analyses.
引用
- Greenberg L, Jairath V, Pearse R, et al. Pre-specification of statistical analysis approaches in published clinical trial protocols was inadequate. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 29864539. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.05.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。