社区招募临床试验受试者需社会与伦理考量
本文描述一项全球慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)临床结局试验中,为补充医院招募而开展的社区招募流程、策略与挑战。在菲律宾五个站点通过入户访谈、COPD lay fora 和肺功能检测营地识别参与者,共访谈3202人,27%可能合格者被转诊,55%成功筛查,9%随机分组。结论认为社区招募可增加受试者数量,但需在规划阶段决定并考虑社会经济文化因素,现行伦理指南间接涉及社区招募问题。
要点
- 社区招募可补充医院招募,但需在试验规划阶段决定。
- 纳入标准复杂导致高筛查失败率。
- 社会准备应考虑社会经济与文化因素。
核心结论
- 社区招募可能增加临床试验受试者数量,取决于要求复杂性。
- 采用社区招募策略应在规划阶段决定以有效协调活动。
- 社会准备应考虑社会经济和文化因素。
- 现行伦理指南和法规间接涉及社区招募问题。
研究设计与样本
- 研究设计为描述社区招募过程、策略与挑战,针对COPD全球临床结局试验。
- 在菲律宾五个站点培训现场人员社区招募策略,通过礼貌电话和社区组织协调,采用入户访谈、COPD lay fora和肺功能检测营地识别合格参与者。
主要发现
- 共访谈3202人,27%可能合格者被转诊至医院站点。
- 55%成功筛查,9%被随机分组。
- 礼貌电话和推荐识别潜在招募对象。
- 沟通、工作、健康状况和家庭成员鼓励影响参与。
- 纳入标准复杂性导致高筛查失败率。
关键数值与推荐
- 访谈3202人,27%可能合格者转诊,55%成功筛查,9%随机分组。
临床怎么用
- 社区招募可作为临床试验受试者来源,但需评估要求复杂性。
- 规划阶段决定社区招募策略,并协调活动。
- 社会准备需考虑社会经济和文化因素。
- 注意沟通、工作、健康状况和家庭因素对参与的影响。
- 在知情同意前确保受试者保护权益。
局限性
- 伦理问题包括在知情同意前使受试者获得完整保护权益。
- 现行伦理指南和法规间接涉及社区招募问题。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This article's objective was to describe the processes, strategies, and challenges of community-based recruitment to complement hospital-based recruitment for a global clinical outcomes trial on chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: To increase the subject recruitment for the clinical research, field staff were trained on community-based recruitment strategies and activities. Courtesy calls and coordination with community organizations were done before recruitment activities. House-to-house interviews using patient referral checklist, lay fora on COPD, and spirometry camps identified eligible participants in five sites in the Philippines. RESULTS: Of 3,202 individuals interviewed, 27% potentially eligible were referred to hospital sites. Of 55% who were successfully screened, 9% were randomized. Courtesy calls and endorsements identified potential recruits. Issues related to communication, work, health condition, and family members' encouragement affected participation. Complexity of the eligibility criteria contributed to the high screen failure rates. Enabling full subject protection entitlements before informed consent taking was one of the ethical issues identified. CONCLUSIONS: Community-based recruitment may increase the number of subjects for clinical trials depending on the complexity of the requirements. Adopting a community-based recruitment strategy must be decided at the planning stage for efficient coordination of activities. Social preparation should consider socioeconomic and cultural factors. Current ethical guidelines and regulations indirectly address issues on community-based recruitment.
引用
- Ladia MAJ, Sison OT, Añonuevo CA, et al. Community-based recruitment for clinical trials poses the need for social and ethical considerations. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 29920291. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.06.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。