慢性疼痛最小临床重要差异因基线疼痛和方法学因素而显著变化:实证研究的系统综述
结果显示,均值变化法的中位绝对MCID为23 mm(0-100 mm量表),相对MCID为34%;阈值法的中位绝对MCID为20 mm,相对MCID为32%,异质性均很高。绝对MCID与基线疼痛强相关,可解释约三分之二的变异。
要点
- 慢性疼痛MCID变异很大,报告时应明确基线疼痛和方法学因素。
- 绝对MCID与基线疼痛强相关,相对MCID则关联较弱。
- 临床分类效应大小时需审慎反思MCID的选择。
核心结论
- 慢性疼痛缓解的MCID变异很大,基线疼痛与绝对MCID强相关,但与相对MCID无关。
- MCID还较小程度受相关疼痛缓解操作定义和临床情况影响。
- 分类效应大小时需明确且审慎地反思MCID的选择。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索PubMed、EMBASE和Cochrane Library。
- 采用均值变化分析或阈值分析确定MCID,因异质性大而进行描述性总结,并用meta分析和亚组分析探索异质性。
主要发现
- 均值变化法:中位绝对MCID为23 mm(0-100 mm量表,IQR 12-39),中位相对MCID为34%(IQR 22-45)。
- 均值变化法异质性很高:绝对MCID I2=99%,相对MCID I2=96%。
- 阈值法:中位绝对MCID为20 mm(IQR 15-30),中位相对MCID为32%(IQR 15-41)。
- 绝对MCID与基线疼痛强相关,解释约三分之二的变异,较小程度与最小疼痛缓解操作定义和临床情况相关。
- 共评估15个临床和方法学因素作为MCID变异的可能原因。
关键数值与推荐
- 均值变化法确定MCID需基于一维疼痛量表、患者报告的过渡量表和均值变化分析。
- 阈值法确定MCID需基于一维疼痛量表、患者报告的过渡量表和阈值分析(最佳敏感度和特异度对应的疼痛减轻)。
临床怎么用
- 在临床指南制定、试验结果解读或样本量规划时,应考虑基线疼痛对绝对MCID的影响。
- 使用MCID分类效应大小时,需明确报告所采用的方法和基线特征。
- 避免将MCID视为固定值,应结合具体临床情况和操作定义进行解释。
局限性
- 因异质性很大,主要结果仅作描述性总结。
- 绝对MCID与基线疼痛的关联基于观察性数据,不能推断因果关系。
- MCID还受其他未完全阐明的因素影响,需进一步研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The minimum clinically important difference (MCID) is used to interpret the relevance of treatment effects, e.g., when developing clinical guidelines, evaluating trial results or planning sample sizes. There is currently no agreement on an appropriate MCID in chronic pain and little is known about which contextual factors cause variation. METHODS: This is a systematic review. We searched PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library. Eligible studies determined MCID for chronic pain based on a one-dimensional pain scale, a patient-reported transition scale of perceived improvement, and either a mean change analysis (mean difference in pain among minimally improved patients) or a threshold analysis (pain reduction associated with best sensitivity and specificity for identifying minimally improved patients). Main results were descriptively summarized due to considerable heterogeneity, which were quantified using meta-analyses and explored using subgroup analyses and metaregression. RESULTS: We included 66 studies (31.254 patients). Median absolute MCID was 23 mm on a 0-100 mm scale (interquartile range [IQR] 12-39) and median relative MCID was 34% (IQR 22-45) among studies using the mean change approach. In both cases, heterogeneity was very high: absolute MCID I2 = 99% and relative MCID I2 = 96%. High variation was also seen among studies using the threshold approach: median absolute MCID was 20 mm (IQR 15-30) and relative MCID was 32% (IQR 15-41). Absolute MCID was strongly associated with baseline pain, explaining approximately two-thirds of the variation, and to a lesser degree with the operational definition of minimum pain relief and clinical condition. A total of 15 clinical and methodological factors were assessed as possible causes for variation in MCID. CONCLUSIONS: MCID for chronic pain relief vary considerably. Baseline pain is strongly associated with absolute, but not relative, measures. To a much lesser degree, MCID is also influenced by the operational definition of relevant pain relief and possibly by clinical condition. Explicit and conscientious reflections on the choice of an MCID are required when classifying effect sizes as clinically important or trivial.
引用
- Olsen MF, Bjerre E, Hansen MD, et al. Minimum clinically important differences in chronic pain vary considerably by baseline pain and methodological factors: systematic review of empirical studies. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 29793007. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.05.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。