Cochrane急性呼吸道感染组利益相关方参与项目确定系统评价优先领域
Cochrane急性呼吸道感染组开展两轮调查的优先级项目,以确定最高优先级的系统评价主题。第一轮154名来自33国的受访者对68个主题排序并提出补充主题,第二轮78名受访者对前25个主题排序。最终形成优先主题清单以指导该组未来24个月的系统评价工作,利益相关方参与提升了过程的透明度与实用性。
要点
- 两轮调查纳入临床医生、研究者、系统评价者、患者等利益相关方。
- 第一轮最常选非特异性急性呼吸道感染、流感和普通感冒主题。
- 第二轮最常选非特异性急性呼吸道感染、肺炎和流感主题。
核心结论
- 项目生成了优先系统评价主题清单,以指导Cochrane ARI组未来24个月的系统评价工作。
- 利益相关方参与提升了过程的透明度,并将增加该组工作对利益相关方的可用性和相关性。
研究设计与样本
- 项目分两阶段,第一阶段分析现有随机对照试验与Cochrane系统评价之间的差距(此前已报告)。
- 第二阶段为两轮调查:第一轮受访者对68个主题排序并可建议最多10个额外主题,第二轮对第一轮前25个主题排序。
- 受访者包括来自33个不同国家的临床医生、研究者、系统评价者、相关健康专业人员、患者和照护者。
主要发现
- 第一轮154名受访者确定了20个优先主题,最常选择非特异性急性呼吸道感染、流感和普通感冒主题。
- 第二轮78名受访者对前25个主题排序,最常涉及非特异性急性呼吸道感染、肺炎和流感领域。
关键数值与推荐
- 第二轮有78名受访者对第一轮前25个主题排序。
- 受访者来自33个不同国家。
临床怎么用
- 优先主题清单可直接用于指导Cochrane ARI组未来24个月的系统评价选题与工作计划。
- 利益相关方参与模式可提升系统评价选题的透明度与对终端用户的可用性和相关性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Cochrane acute respiratory infections (ARIs) group conducts systematic reviews of the evidence for treatment and prevention of ARIs. We report the results of a prioritization project, aiming to identify highest priority systematic review topics. STUDY DESIGN/SETTING: The project consisted of two phases. Phase 1 analyzed the gap between existing randomized controlled trials and Cochrane systematic reviews (reported previously). Phase 2 (reported here) consisted of a two-round survey. In round 1, respondents prioritized 68 topics and suggested up to 10 additional topics; in round 2, respondents prioritized top 25 topics from round 1. RESULTS: Respondents included clinicians, researchers, systematic reviewers, allied health, patients, and carers, from 33 different countries. In round 1, 154 respondents identified 20 priority topics, most commonly selecting topics in nonspecific ARIs, influenza, and common cold. Fifty respondents also collectively suggested 134 additional topics. In round 2, 78 respondents prioritized top 25 topics, most commonly in the areas of nonspecific ARIs, pneumonia, and influenza. CONCLUSION: We generated a list of priority systematic review topics to guide the Cochrane ARI group's systematic review work for the next 24 months. Stakeholder involvement enhanced the transparency of the process and will increase the usability and relevance of the group's work to stakeholders.
引用
- Scott AM, Clark J, Dooley L, et al. Cochrane acute respiratory infections group's stakeholder engagement project identified systematic review priority areas. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 29800690. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.05.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。