文献速递流行病学与生物统计

随机实验中Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney检验的因果估计量与置信区间

Causal estimands and confidence intervals associated with Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney tests in randomized experiments.
PubMed 文献 · Stat Med · 2018-05-17

本文探讨随机实验中Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney检验的因果解释,指出其自然参数Mann-Whitney参数ϕ可视为因果参数,但与不可识别的因果效应ψ不同。Hand悖论表明ϕ与ψ可能给出相反结论,ψ需非参数假设界定,比例优势参数在1/9至9之间可能发生悖论。以疫苗试验为例演示。

要点

  • Mann-Whitney参数ϕ是因果参数,但不同于不可识别的ψ。
  • Hand悖论:ϕ与ψ可能对治疗优劣给出相反结论。
  • 比例优势参数在1/9至9之间可能发生Hand悖论。

核心结论

  • Mann-Whitney参数ϕ可框架为因果参数,但与不可识别的因果效应ψ不同。
  • Hand悖论表明ϕ可能显示治疗更优而ψ显示更差(或相反)。

研究设计与样本

  • 方法学论文,讨论随机实验中Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney检验的因果估计量。
  • 使用疫苗试验作为示例演示相关问题。

主要发现

  • Mann-Whitney参数ϕ衡量治疗组随机个体反应大于对照组随机个体的概率(含结调整)。
  • ψ为同一随机个体在治疗与对照下反应更大的概率(含结调整),不可从随机实验识别。
  • 比例优势参数在1/9至9之间时Hand悖论可能发生。

关键数值与推荐

  • Mann-Whitney参数ϕ定义:治疗组随机个体反应大于对照组随机个体的概率(加结调整)。
  • ψ定义:同一随机个体治疗下反应大于对照下的概率(加结调整)。
  • 比例优势参数在1/9至9之间可能发生Hand悖论。

临床怎么用

  • 报告Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney检验时建议同时给出Mann-Whitney参数的因果估计量及置信区间。
  • 解释ϕ时需注意其与不可识别ψ的区别,避免因果误读。

局限性

  • ψ不可从随机实验识别,需依赖非参数假设通过界进行推断。
  • Hand悖论在比例优势参数1/9至9范围内可能发生,需较大效应才能避免。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Although the P value from a Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test is used often with randomized experiments, it is rarely accompanied with a causal effect estimate and its confidence interval. The natural parameter for the Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test is the Mann-Whitney parameter, ϕ, which measures the probability that a randomly selected individual in the treatment arm will have a larger response than a randomly selected individual in the control arm (plus an adjustment for ties). We show that the Mann-Whitney parameter may be framed as a causal parameter and show that it is not equal to a closely related and nonidentifiable causal effect, ψ, the probability that a randomly selected individual will have a larger response under treatment than under control (plus an adjustment for ties). We review the paradox, first expressed by Hand, that the ψ parameter may imply that the treatment is worse (or better) than control, while the Mann-Whitney parameter shows the opposite. Unlike the Mann-Whitney parameter, ψ is nonidentifiable from a randomized experiment. We review some nonparametric assumptions that rule out Hand's paradox through bounds on ψ and use bootstrap methods to make inferences on those bounds. We explore the relationship of the proportional odds parameter to Hand's paradox, showing that the paradox may occur for proportional odds parameters between 1/9 and 9. Thus, large effects are needed to ensure that if treatment appears better by the Mann-Whitney parameter, then treatment improves responses in most individuals. We demonstrate these issues using a vaccine trial.

来源:Stat Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fay MP, Brittain EH, Shih JH, et al. Causal estimands and confidence intervals associated with Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney tests in randomized experiments. Stat Med. 2018. PMID: 29774591. doi:10.1002/sim.7799

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。