临床医生是否需要推荐意见?比较含与不含GRADE推荐意见的证据摘要的多中心研究
该多中心随机研究纳入10个国家参加教育会议的执业临床医生,比较低或极低确定性证据摘要是否附带GRADE强或弱推荐意见对偏好、理解及预期行动的影响。所有情景中正确理解证据摘要信息者不足一半;在两个强推荐情景中,附带推荐意见使预期行动更适当。结论认为仅证据摘要不足以影响临床医生行动,临床医生明确偏好证据摘要附带推荐意见。
要点
- 临床医生明确偏好证据摘要附带推荐意见:强推荐86%、弱推荐81%。
- 所有情景中正确理解证据摘要信息(如效应估计、证据确定性)者不足一半。
- 两个强推荐情景中,附带推荐意见使预期行动更适当。
核心结论
- 仅证据摘要不足以影响临床医生的行动。
- 在低或极低确定性证据背景下,临床医生明确偏好证据摘要附带推荐意见。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心随机研究,纳入10个国家参加教育会议的执业临床医生。
- 参与者随机接受低或极低确定性研究证据支持的临床情景,并附带GRADE强或弱推荐意见。
- 每组内进一步随机接受推荐意见加相应证据摘要,或仅证据摘要。
主要发现
- 248人中201人(81%)偏好证据摘要附带弱推荐。
- 所有情景中正确理解证据摘要提供信息(如效应估计、研究证据确定性)的参与者不足一半。
- 在两个涉及强推荐的情景中,附带推荐意见使预期行动更适当。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Evidence-based clinical practice guidelines provide recommendations to assist clinicians in decision-making and to reduce the gap between best current research evidence and clinical practice. However, some argue that providing preappraised evidence summaries alone, rather than recommendations, is more appropriate. The objective of the study is to evaluate clinicians' preferences, and understanding of the evidence and intended course of action in response to evidence summaries with and without recommendations. STUDY DESIGN SETTING: We included practicing clinicians attending educational sessions across 10 countries. Clinicians were randomized to receive relevant clinical scenarios supported by research evidence of low or very low certainty and accompanied by either strong or weak recommendations developed with the GRADE system. Within each group, participants were further randomized to receive the recommendation plus the corresponding evidence summary or the evidence summary alone. We evaluated participants' preferences and understanding for the presentation strategy, as well as their intended course of action. RESULTS: One hundred eighty-nine of 219 (86%) and 201 of 248 (81%) participants preferred having recommendations accompanying evidence summaries for both strong and weak recommendations, respectively. Across all scenarios, less than half of participants correctly interpreted information provided in the evidences summaries (e.g., estimates of effect, certainty in the research evidence). The presence of a recommendation resulted in a more appropriate intended course of action for two scenarios involving strong recommendations. CONCLUSION: Evidence summaries alone are not enough to impact clinicians' course of action. Clinicians clearly prefer having recommendations accompanying evidence summaries in the context of low or very low certainty of evidence (Trial registration NCT02006017).
引用
- Neumann I, Alonso-Coello P, Vandvik PO, et al. Do clinicians want recommendations? A multicenter study comparing evidence summaries with and without GRADE recommendations. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 29530644. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2018.02.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。