文献速递流行病学与生物统计临床试验与 GCP医学教育与科研方法

多数随机临床试验可能缺乏正当性:随机临床试验伦理与科学的横断面分析

Many randomized clinical trials may not be justified: a cross-sectional analysis of the ethics and science of randomized clinical trials.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2018-01-03

该横断面分析纳入2015年《新英格兰医学杂志》和《美国医学会杂志》发表的208篇RCT文章及199份方案,评估三项科学标准:明确假设、存在不确定性、通过系统综述确立不确定性。仅44%的合并文本包含全部三项标准,56%未满足三项标准,可能因此在科学和伦理上缺乏正当性。

要点

  • 仅44%的RCT合并文本同时满足明确假设、存在不确定性及系统综述三项科学标准。
  • 76%的RCT合并文本有明确陈述的假设,99%提及某种形式的不确定性。
  • 54%的RCT合并文本引用了相关系统综述或荟萃分析,仅10%提及「均势」、11%提及「共识」。

核心结论

  • 多数RCT(56%)未满足三项科学标准,可能因此在科学和伦理上缺乏正当性。
  • 建议放弃将「均势」「临床均势」和「缺乏共识」作为RCT的科学标准,代之以期望RCT具有明确、有意义的假设,并通过系统综述确立围绕该假设的不确定性。

研究设计与样本

  • 对2015年《新英格兰医学杂志》和《美国医学会杂志》发表的所有RCT进行横断面分析,共纳入208篇RCT文章和199份方案。
  • 每篇文章和方案均评估四项内容:明确陈述的核心假设、提及「均势」或「共识」、某种证据不确定性的指示、围绕假设或研究问题的荟萃分析或系统综述。

主要发现

  • 在合并的文章和方案中,76%有明确陈述的假设,99%提及某种形式的不确定性,54%引用了相关系统综述或荟萃分析。
  • 仅44%的合并文本包含全部三项科学标准。
  • 提及「均势」的占10%,提及「共识」的占11%,且提及均势者最常与公认定义不一致。

关键数值与推荐

  • 三项科学标准:(1)围绕明确假设设计;(2)该假设存在不确定性;(3)不确定性通过系统综述确立。
  • 76%有明确假设,99%提及不确定性,54%引用系统综述或荟萃分析,44%包含全部三项标准。

临床怎么用

  • 原文建议放弃将「均势」「临床均势」和「缺乏共识」作为RCT的科学标准。
  • 原文建议代之以期望RCT具有明确、有意义的假设,并通过系统综述确立围绕该假设的不确定性。

局限性

  • 原文未述局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: We have proposed that three scientific criteria are important for the ethical justification of randomized clinical trials (RCTs): (1) they should be designed around a clear hypothesis; (2) uncertainty should exist around that hypothesis; (3) that uncertainty should be as established through a systematic review. We hypothesized that the majority of a sample of recently published RCTs would not explicitly incorporate these criteria, therefore rendering them potentially unjustified on scientific grounds. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Cross-sectional analysis of all RCTs published in the New England Journal of Medicine and the Journal of the American Medical Association in 2015. Each article and protocol was reviewed for: (1) a clearly stated central hypothesis; (2) references to "equipoise," or "consensus;" (3) some indication of evidentiary uncertainty; (4) a meta-analysis or systematic review surrounding the hypothesis or study question. RESULTS: We included 208 RCT articles and 199 protocols. Among combined articles and protocols, 76% had a clearly stated hypothesis, 99% referenced some form of uncertainty, and 54% cited a relevant systematic review or meta-analysis. Only 44% of combined texts contained all three scientific criteria. There were few references to "equipoise" (10%) or "consensus" (11%), and those references to equipoise were most often inconsistent with accepted definitions. CONCLUSION: The majority of RCTs (56%) did not meet the three scientific criteria described previously and therefore may be scientifically and therefore ethically unjustified. We recommend that "equipoise," "clinical equipoise," and "lack of consensus" be abandoned as scientific criteria for RCTs and be replaced by an expectation that RCTs have a clearly stated, meaningful hypothesis around which uncertainty has been established through a systematic review of the literature.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. De Meulemeester J, Fedyk M, Jurkovic L, et al. Many randomized clinical trials may not be justified: a cross-sectional analysis of the ethics and science of randomized clinical trials. J Clin Epidemiol. 2018. PMID: 29306063. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.12.027

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。