高斯个体患者数据Meta分析:两阶段与否?
本文讨论高斯个体患者数据Meta分析中一阶段与两阶段方法的选择。作者从灵活性和精度两方面进行统计论证,指出仅能一阶段拟合的模型多数Meta分析者可能并不关注;在特定假设下,两阶段与一阶段拟合同一模型的精度近似相等。结论是Meta分析者应谨慎选择建模假设,若相关模型仅能一阶段拟合则用一阶段,否则可选用最方便的方法拟合既定模型。
要点
- 仅能一阶段拟合的模型多数Meta分析者可能并不关注。
- 在特定假设下,两阶段与一阶段拟合同一模型的精度近似相等。
- Meta分析者应谨慎选择建模假设,有时相关模型仅能一阶段拟合。
核心结论
- Meta分析者应谨慎选择建模假设;有时相关模型仅能一阶段拟合,否则可自由选用最方便的方法拟合既定模型。
研究设计与样本
- 针对高斯个体患者数据,从灵活性与精度两方面讨论一阶段与两阶段Meta分析的统计论证。
主要发现
- 支持一阶段者认为可拟合更广模型且总体估计可能更精确;支持两阶段者认为两阶段可拟合的模型足以回答相关问题且建模选择少、出错空间小。
- 关于灵活性,仅能一阶段拟合的若干模型可能并非多数Meta分析实践者真正关注。
- 关于精度,对固定效应与随机效应Meta分析,在模型满足特定假设时,拟合该模型所用阶段数无关,精度近似相等。
临床怎么用
- Meta分析者应谨慎选择建模假设,若相关模型仅能一阶段拟合则采用一阶段,否则可选用最方便的方法拟合既定模型。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Quantitative evidence synthesis through meta-analysis is central to evidence-based medicine. For well-documented reasons, the meta-analysis of individual patient data is held in higher regard than aggregate data. With access to individual patient data, the analysis is not restricted to a "two-stage" approach (combining estimates and standard errors) but can estimate parameters of interest by fitting a single model to all of the data, a so-called "one-stage" analysis. There has been debate about the merits of one- and two-stage analysis. Arguments for one-stage analysis have typically noted that a wider range of models can be fitted and overall estimates may be more precise. The two-stage side has emphasised that the models that can be fitted in two stages are sufficient to answer the relevant questions, with less scope for mistakes because there are fewer modelling choices to be made in the two-stage approach. For Gaussian data, we consider the statistical arguments for flexibility and precision in small-sample settings. Regarding flexibility, several of the models that can be fitted only in one stage may not be of serious interest to most meta-analysis practitioners. Regarding precision, we consider fixed- and random-effects meta-analysis and see that, for a model making certain assumptions, the number of stages used to fit this model is irrelevant; the precision will be approximately equal. Meta-analysts should choose modelling assumptions carefully. Sometimes relevant models can only be fitted in one stage. Otherwise, meta-analysts are free to use whichever procedure is most convenient to fit the identified model.
引用
- Morris TP, Fisher DJ, Kenward MG, et al. Meta-analysis of Gaussian individual patient data: Two-stage or not two-stage? Stat Med. 2018. PMID: 29349792. doi:10.1002/sim.7589
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。