前瞻性注册与系统评价报告及方法学质量的关联:一项meta-流行病学研究
该研究检索PubMed获取2015年发表的随机对照试验系统评价,分为注册非Cochrane、Cochrane和未注册三组各随机抽取50篇,比较报告与方法学质量。注册系统评价的总R-AMSTAR评分高于未注册(MD=4.82,95%CI:3.70,5.94),总PRISMA评分亦较高(MD=1.47,95%CI:0.64-2.30),但剔除注册相关条目后PRISMA差异不再显著。结论提示前瞻性注册可能至少间接改善方法学质量。
要点
- 注册系统评价的总R-AMSTAR评分高于未注册(MD=4.82,95%CI:3.70,5.94)。
- 注册系统评价的总PRISMA评分高于未注册(MD=1.47,95%CI:0.64-2.30)。
- 剔除注册相关条目后,总PRISMA评分差异不再有统计学意义。
核心结论
- 前瞻性注册可能至少间接改善系统评价的总体方法学质量,尽管其对总体报告质量的影响不显著。
研究设计与样本
- 检索PubMed识别2015年发表的随机对照试验系统评价,分为注册非Cochrane、Cochrane和未注册三组,每组随机抽取50篇合格研究。
- 提取系统评价数据,采用回归分析探索总R-AMSTAR或PRISMA评分与所选特征的关联。
主要发现
- 注册系统评价的文献检索实施与报告优于未注册系统评价,11个R-AMSTAR条目中有9个差异有统计学意义。
- 注册系统评价的总R-AMSTAR评分高于未注册(MD=4.82,95%CI:3.70,5.94),剔除注册相关条目后结果相似(MD=4.34,95%CI:3.28,5.40)。
- 注册系统评价的总PRISMA评分显著高于未注册(全部系统评价:MD=1.47,95%CI:0.64-2.30;非Cochrane系统评价:MD=1.49,95%CI:0.56-2.42)。
- 剔除注册相关条目(条目5)后,总PRISMA评分差异不再有统计学意义,回归分析结果相似。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to investigate the differences in main characteristics, reporting and methodological quality between prospectively registered and nonregistered systematic reviews. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: PubMed was searched to identify systematic reviews of randomized controlled trials published in 2015 in English. After title and abstract screening, potentially relevant reviews were divided into three groups: registered non-Cochrane reviews, Cochrane reviews, and nonregistered reviews. For each group, random number tables were generated in Microsoft Excel, and the first 50 eligible studies from each group were randomly selected. Data of interest from systematic reviews were extracted. Regression analyses were conducted to explore the association between total Revised Assessment of Multiple Systematic Review (R-AMSTAR) or Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) scores and the selected characteristics of systematic reviews. RESULTS: The conducting and reporting of literature search in registered reviews were superior to nonregistered reviews. Differences in 9 of the 11 R-AMSTAR items were statistically significant between registered and nonregistered reviews. The total R-AMSTAR score of registered reviews was higher than nonregistered reviews [mean difference (MD) = 4.82, 95% confidence interval (CI): 3.70, 5.94]. Sensitivity analysis by excluding the registration-related item presented similar result (MD = 4.34, 95% CI: 3.28, 5.40). Total PRISMA scores of registered reviews were significantly higher than nonregistered reviews (all reviews: MD = 1.47, 95% CI: 0.64-2.30; non-Cochrane reviews: MD = 1.49, 95% CI: 0.56-2.42). However, the difference in the total PRISMA score was no longer statistically significant after excluding the item related to registration (item 5). Regression analyses showed similar results. CONCLUSION: Prospective registration may at least indirectly improve the overall methodological quality of systematic reviews, although its impact on the overall reporting quality was not significant.
引用
- Ge L, Tian JH, Li YN, et al. Association between prospective registration and overall reporting and methodological quality of systematic reviews: a meta-epidemiological study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 29111471. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.10.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。