龋病预防与管理随机对照试验的结局报告:一项系统综述
该系统综述检索了PubMed、Embase、Web of Knowledge和Cochrane CENTRAL(1968年1月1日至2015年8月25日),纳入605篇龋病预防或管理RCT,映射其报告的结局。结果显示龋病经历报告比例从1968-1980年的39%降至2001-2010年的18%,修复体临床性能报告在该两时段从33%升至42%但2011-2015年降至22%,患者报告结局使用仍低。
要点
- 龋病经历报告比例从1968-1980年的39%降至2001-2010年的18%。
- 修复体临床性能报告从1968-1980年的33%升至2001-2010年的42%,2011-2015年降至22%。
- 仅414篇(68%)报告明确标识了主要结局。
核心结论
- 过去50年龋病预防与管理试验的结局报告倾向于聚焦龋病经历和修复材料临床性能,病损活动和成本效果报告增多,患者报告结局虽更常见但仍使用较少。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索PubMed、Embase、Web of Knowledge和Cochrane CENTRAL(1968年1月1日至2015年8月25日),纳入605篇比较龋病预防或管理技术或支持龋病治疗患者的RCT。
主要发现
- 在1968-1980年和2001-2010年两个时段,所有结局中龋病经历的报告比例从39%降至18%。
- 修复体临床性能的报告比例从1968-1980年的33%升至2001-2010年的42%,但2011-2015年降至22%。
- 病损活动结局领域在1968-1980年占1%、2011-2015年占10%;牙髓健康相关结局在1968-1980年占0%、2011-2015年占4%。
- 资源效率和生存质量测量的报告一直处于低水平,无出版物报告独立于DMFT或等效指数的牙齿生存。
- 414篇(68%)报告明确标识了主要结局。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Inconsistent outcome reporting is one significant hurdle to combining results from trials into systematic reviews. Core outcome sets (COS) can reduce this barrier. The aim of this review was to map outcomes reported in caries prevention and management randomised controlled trials (RCT) as a first step to COS development. We also investigated RCT characteristics and reporting of primary outcomes and sample size calculations. METHODS: PubMed, Embase, Web of Knowledge and Cochrane CENTRAL were systematically searched (1 January 1968 to 25 August 2015). INCLUSION CRITERIA: RCTs comparing any technique for prevention or management of caries with another or placebo and RCTs comparing interventions to support patients undergoing treatment of caries (without setting, dentition or age restrictions). Categories were developed through piloting and group consensus and outcomes grouped accordingly. RESULTS: Of 4773 search results, 764 were potentially relevant, full text was available for 731 papers and 605 publications met the inclusion criteria and were included. For all outcomes across the time periods 1968-1980 and 2001-2010, reporting of outcome 'caries experience' reduced from 39% to 18%; 'clinical performance of the restoration' reporting increased from 33% to 42% although there was a reduction to 22% in 2011-2015. Emerging outcome domains include 'lesion activity' and 'pulp health-related outcomes', accounting for 1% and 0%, respectively, during 1968-1980 and 10% and 4% for 2011-2015. Reporting 'resource efficiency' and 'quality of life measures' have remained at a low level. No publications reported tooth survival independent of an index such as DMFT or equivalent. Primary outcomes were only identified as such in 414 (68%) of the reports. CONCLUSIONS: Over the past 50 years, outcome reporting for trials on prevention and management of carious lesions have tended to focus on outcomes measuring caries experience and restoration material clinical performance with lesion activity and cost-effectiveness increasingly being reported. Patient-reported and patient-focused outcomes are becoming more common (although as secondary outcomes) but remain low in use. The challenge with developing a COS will be balancing commonly previously reported outcomes against those more relevant for the future. TRIAL REGISTRATION: PROSPERO, CRD42015025310 . Registered on 14 August 2015, Trials (Schwendicke et al., Trials 16:397, 2015) and COMET initiative online (COMET, 2017).
引用
- Levey C, Innes N, Schwendicke F, et al. Outcomes in randomised controlled trials in prevention and management of carious lesions: a systematic review. Trials. 2017. PMID: 29096680. doi:10.1186/s13063-017-2256-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。