美国制药与医疗器械企业向美国医学期刊编辑支付的款项:回顾性观察研究
该回顾性观察研究利用2014年美国开放支付数据库,分析了52种美国医学期刊713名副主编及以上编辑接受制药与医疗器械企业支付的情况。50.6%的编辑接受了通用支付,19.5%接受了研究支付,中位通用支付为11美元,但均值达28136美元。作者认为企业支付常见且金额有时较大,期刊应考虑其对公众信任的潜在影响。
要点
- 713名编辑中361人(50.6%)2014年接受过通用支付,139人(19.5%)接受过研究支付。
- 通用支付中位数11美元(四分位距0-2923),均值28136美元(标准差415045)。
- 内分泌科编辑通用支付中位数最高,为7207美元(0-85816)。
核心结论
- 企业向期刊编辑支付款项常见且金额有时较大,某些亚专科尤为突出。
- 作者认为期刊应考虑此类支付对已发表研究公众信任的潜在影响。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性观察研究,纳入26个专科的52种有影响力(本专科高影响因子)美国医学期刊。
- 从各期刊在线编委名单识别713名副主编及以上编辑,匹配2014年美国开放支付数据库。
主要发现
- 713名合格编辑中,361人(50.6%)2014年接受过通用支付(>$0),139人(19.5%)接受过研究支付。
- 通用支付中位数11美元(四分位距0-2923),均值28136美元(标准差415045)。
- 研究支付中位数0美元(四分位距0-0),均值37963美元(标准差175239)。
- 高影响因子综合医学期刊编辑通用支付中位数为0美元(0-14)。
- 52种期刊网站中17种(32.7%)的编辑利益冲突政策可在五分钟内便捷获取。
关键数值与推荐
- 通用支付中位数最高的专科:内分泌科7207美元(0-85816),心内科2664美元(0-12912),消化科696美元(0-20002),风湿科515美元(0-14280),泌尿科480美元(90-669)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective To estimate financial payments from industry to US journal editors.Design Retrospective observational study.Setting 52 influential (high impact factor for their specialty) US medical journals from 26 specialties and US Open Payments database, 2014.Participants 713 editors at the associate level and above identified from each journal's online masthead.Main outcome measures All general payments (eg, personal income) and research related payments from pharmaceutical and medical device manufacturers to eligible physicians in 2014. Percentages of editors receiving payments and the magnitude of such payments were compared across journals and by specialty. Journal websites were also reviewed to determine if conflict of interest policies for editors were readily accessible.Results Of 713 eligible editors, 361 (50.6%) received some (>$0) general payments in 2014, and 139 (19.5%) received research payments. The median general payment was $11 (£8; €9) (interquartile range $0-2923) and the median research payment was $0 ($0-0). The mean general payment was $28 136 (SD $415 045), and the mean research payment was $37 963 (SD $175 239). The highest median general payments were received by journal editors from endocrinology ($7207, $0-85 816), cardiology ($2664, $0-12 912), gastroenterology ($696, $0-20 002), rheumatology ($515, $0-14 280), and urology ($480, $90-669). For high impact general medicine journals, median payments were $0 ($0-14). A review of the 52 journal websites revealed that editor conflict of interest policies were readily accessible (ie, within five minutes) for 17/52 (32.7%) of journals.Conclusions Industry payments to journal editors are common and often large, particularly for certain subspecialties. Journals should consider the potential impact of such payments on public trust in published research.
引用
- Liu JJ, Bell CM, Matelski JJ, et al. Payments by US pharmaceutical and medical device manufacturers to US medical journal editors: retrospective observational study. BMJ. 2017. PMID: 29074628. doi:10.1136/bmj.j4619
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。