一项随机试验比较三种德尔菲反馈策略在高初始一致性场景下未发现差异
该随机试验嵌套于两轮德尔菲调查中,用于制定前列腺癌核心结局集,纳入卫生专业人员和患者两个利益相关群体,对79个结局按1至9分评分,第二轮将参与者随机分配接受仅同行反馈、多利益相关方分别反馈或多利益相关方合并反馈。结果显示各反馈组保留结局的一致性均较高(同行92%、多分别90%、多合并84%),不同反馈策略在保留结局数量或意见变异性降低方面未发现差异,可能归因于第一轮已存在高一致性。
要点
- 各反馈组保留结局的一致性均较高:同行反馈92%、多利益相关方分别反馈90%、多利益相关方合并反馈84%。
- 同行反馈与多分别反馈之间(0.016 [-0.035, 0.067];P = 0.529)及多分别与多合并反馈之间(0.063 [-0.003, 0.129];P = 0.062)变异性降低均未达统计学显著。
- 同行反馈较合并反馈在变异性降低上达统计学显著(0.079 [0.001, 0.157];P = 0.046)。
核心结论
- 不同反馈策略在保留结局数量或意见变异性降低方面未发现差异,可能归因于第一轮已存在的高水平一致性,需进一步的方法学研究来阐明最佳策略。
研究设计与样本
- 一项两轮德尔菲调查,结局清单来源于系统评价结果和访谈,用于制定前列腺癌核心结局集,纳入卫生专业人员和患者两个利益相关群体。
- 共79个结局按1分(不重要)至9分(至关重要)评分,第二轮参与者被随机分配接受仅同行反馈、多利益相关方分别反馈或多利益相关方合并反馈。
主要发现
- 所有反馈组保留结局的一致性均较高:同行反馈92%、多利益相关方分别反馈90%、多利益相关方合并反馈84%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为不同反馈策略在保留结局数量或意见变异性降低方面未发现差异,可能归因于第一轮已存在的高水平一致性。
- 作者建议将进一步的方法学研究嵌套于德尔菲调查中以帮助阐明最佳策略。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
- 原文结论指出该结果可能归因于第一轮已存在的高水平一致性,并指出需进一步的方法学研究来阐明最佳策略。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The objective of the study was to explore the impact of different feedback strategies on (1) subsequent agreement and (2) variability in Delphi studies. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A two-round Delphi survey, with a list of outcomes generated from the results of a systematic review and interviews, was undertaken while developing a core outcomes set for prostate cancer including two stakeholder groups (health professionals and patients). Seventy-nine outcomes were scored on a scale of one (not important) to nine (critically important). Participants were randomized in round 2 to receive round 1 feedback from peers only, multiple stakeholders separately, or multiple stakeholders combined. RESULTS: Agreement on outcomes retained for all feedback groups was high (peer: 92%, multiple separate: 90%, multiple combined: 84%). There were no statistically significant reduction in variability for peer vs. multiple separate (0.016 [-0.035, 0.067]; P = 0.529), or multiple separate vs. multiple combined feedback (0.063 [-0.003, 0.129]; P = 0.062). Peer feedback statistically significantly reduced variability compared with multiple combined feedback (0.079 [0.001, 0.157]; P = 0.046). CONCLUSIONS: We found no evidence of a difference between different feedback strategies in terms of the number of outcomes retained or reduction in variability of opinion. However, this may be explained by the high level of existing agreement in round 1. Further methodological studies nested within Delphi surveys will help clarify the best strategy.
引用
- MacLennan S, Kirkham J, Lam TBL, et al. A randomized trial comparing three Delphi feedback strategies found no evidence of a difference in a setting with high initial agreement. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 29017811. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.09.024
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。