系统综述发现临床试验中伦理批准、知情同意和激励措施的报告不足
该系统综述检索排名前50的医学期刊获取2000篇最新文献,纳入927项原始临床试验,发现14项(1.5%)未报告伦理声明,三分之二(63%)未完整报告伦理委员会批准、赫尔辛基宣言和知情同意等要素,21项(2.26%)报告了激励措施,仅1项报告了本地伦理委员会信息,作者呼吁作者和期刊加强伦理相关报告。
要点
- 927项试验中14项(1.5%)未报告伦理声明,63%未完整报告伦理相关要素。
- 仅21项(2.26%)报告了激励措施,其中15项提供不同形式的金钱激励,6项主要为医疗福利。
- 仅1项试验报告了本地伦理委员会的信息或质量。
核心结论
- 本综述指出了伦理声明和财务激励报告实践中可能存在的差距。
- 作者敦促作者完整报告所有与研究相关的伦理要素,包括激励和补偿计划。
- 建议医学期刊实施更多关于伦理报告的发表要求。
研究设计与样本
- 通过Scimago排名对排名前50的医学期刊进行系统检索,获取2000篇最新发表的文献。
- 仅纳入原始临床试验,对语言和参与者无限制,最终纳入927项试验。
主要发现
- 在927项纳入试验中,14项(1.5%)未报告伦理声明。
- 三分之二(63%)的试验未完整报告所调查的组成部分(机构审查委员会批准、赫尔辛基宣言和知情同意)。
- 21项试验(2.26%)报告了激励措施及支付方法和金额;其中15项以不同形式向参与者提供金钱激励,其余6项激励主要为医疗福利。
- 仅1项试验报告了本地机构审查委员会的信息或质量。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议作者完整报告所有与研究相关的伦理要素,包括激励和补偿计划。
- 作者建议医学期刊实施更多关于伦理报告的发表要求。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: In this study, we aim to review researchers' reporting practices of the ethics statement, financial incentives, and local ethical committees' profile in their clinical trials. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A systematic search was done through top-ranked 50 medical journals (Scimago Ranking) to retrieve 2,000 latest publications. Only primary clinical trials were included with no restriction to language or participants. RESULTS: Among the 927 included trials, 14 trials (1.5%) did not report an ethical statement and two-third (63%) did not completely report the investigated components (Institutional Review eBoard approval, Helsinki Declaration, and informed consent). Moreover, 21 trials (2.26%) reported motivational incentives with the method and amount of payment for participants. Of them, 15 trials offered monetary incentives to participants in different forms. In the remaining six trials, the incentives were mainly medical benefits. Only one trial reported the profile or quality of local Institutional Review Board. CONCLUSION: A potential gap in the reporting practices of ethics statement and financial incentives was addressed in this review. Authors are urged to fully report all ethical components related to their study, including incentives and compensations plan. Medical journals are also recommended to implement further publication requirements concerning ethics reporting.
引用
- Trung LQ, Morra ME, Truong ND, et al. A systematic review finds underreporting of ethics approval, informed consent, and incentives in clinical trials. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 28866123. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.08.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。