推荐药物抗土源性蠕虫感染的疗效:系统综述与网络Meta分析
该系统综述与网络Meta分析纳入55项(治愈率)和46项(虫卵减少率)随机对照试验,评估阿苯达唑、甲苯达唑、左旋咪唑和双羟萘酸噻嘧啶单剂方案对蛔虫、钩虫和鞭虫的疗效;阿苯达唑对钩虫治愈率79.5%、虫卵减少率89.6%,所有药物对鞭虫疗效低,甲苯达唑治愈率42.1%、虫卵减少率66.0%;阿苯达唑对鞭虫的疗效在1995至2015年间显著下降。
要点
- 阿苯达唑对钩虫感染治愈率79.5%(95%CI 71.5%至85.6%),虫卵减少率89.6%(81.9%至97.3%)。
- 所有药物对鞭虫疗效低,甲苯达唑治愈率最高为42.1%(25.9%至60.2%)。
- 阿苯达唑对鞭虫虫卵减少率从1995年72.6%降至2015年43.4%(P=0.049),治愈率从38.6%降至16.4%(P=0.027)。
核心结论
- 所有四种现行推荐药物在疗效上均存在局限性;仅阿苯达唑对钩虫感染显示良好疗效,所有药物对鞭虫疗效低,阿苯达唑对鞭虫疗效近二十年下降值得关注,提示需加强开发新药尤其是针对鞭虫的药物。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与网络Meta分析,检索PubMed、ISI Web of Science、Embase、ScienceDirect、Cochrane Central Register of Clinical Trials和世界卫生组织图书馆数据库自1960年至2016年12月31日的文献,纳入评估阿苯达唑、甲苯达唑、左旋咪唑和双羟萘酸噻嘧啶单剂方案治疗蛔虫、钩虫和鞭虫的随机对照试验。
- 治愈率分析纳入55项随机对照试验,虫卵减少率分析纳入46项随机对照试验。
主要发现
- 所有药物对蛔虫均高度有效。
- 阿苯达唑对钩虫感染疗效最高,治愈率79.5%(95%CI 71.5%至85.6%),虫卵减少率89.6%(81.9%至97.3%)。
- 所有药物对鞭虫疗效低,甲苯达唑治愈率最高为42.1%(95%CI 25.9%至60.2%),虫卵减少率66.0%(54.6%至77.3%)。
- 1995年和2015年的估计显示阿苯达唑对鞭虫的疗效显著下降:至2015年虫卵减少率从72.6%(53.7%至91.5%)降至43.4%(23.5%至63.3%;P=0.049),治愈率从38.6%(26.2%至52.7%)降至16.4%(7.7%至31.3%;P=0.027)。
关键数值与推荐
- 阿苯达唑对钩虫治愈率79.5%(95%CI 71.5%至85.6%),虫卵减少率89.6%(81.9%至97.3%)。
- 甲苯达唑对鞭虫治愈率42.1%(95%CI 25.9%至60.2%),虫卵减少率66.0%(54.6%至77.3%)。
- 阿苯达唑对鞭虫虫卵减少率1995年72.6%(53.7%至91.5%) vs 2015年43.4%(23.5%至63.3%)(2015年较1995年降低,P=0.049)。
- 阿苯达唑对鞭虫治愈率1995年38.6%(26.2%至52.7%) vs 2015年16.4%(7.7%至31.3%)(2015年较1995年降低,P=0.027)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出所有四种现行推荐药物在疗效上均存在局限性,仅阿苯达唑对钩虫感染显示良好疗效,所有药物对鞭虫疗效低,阿苯达唑对鞭虫疗效下降值得关注,提示需加强开发新药尤其是针对鞭虫的药物。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective To evaluate efficacies of anthelmintic drugs against soil transmitted helminths in terms of cure rates and egg reduction rates.Design Systematic review and network meta-analysis.Data Sources PubMed, ISI Web of Science, Embase, ScienceDirect, the Cochrane Central Register of Clinical Trials, and the World Health Organization library database from 1960 until 31 December 2016.Study selection Randomised controlled trials evaluating the efficacy of a single dose regimen of albendazole, mebendazole, levamisole, and pyrantel pamoate against Ascaris lumbricoides, hookworm (Necator americanus and Ancylostoma duodenale) and Trichuris trichiura. The primary outcomes included cure rates analysed by network meta-analysis with mixed logistic regression models and egg reduction rates with mixed linear models.Results 55 and 46 randomised controlled trials were included in the analysis of cure rates and egg reduction rates, respectively. All drugs were highly efficacious against A lumbricoides Albendazole showed the highest efficacy against hookworm infections with a cure rate of 79.5% (95% confidence interval 71.5% to 85.6%) and an egg reduction rate of 89.6% (81.9% to 97.3%). All drugs had low efficacy against T trichiura, with mebendazole showing the highest cure rate of 42.1% (25.9% to 60.2%) and egg reduction rate of 66.0% (54.6% to 77.3%). Estimates for the years 1995 and 2015 showed significant reductions in efficacy of albendazole against T trichiura: by 2015 the egg reduction rates fell from 72.6% (53.7% to 91.5%) to 43.4% (23.5% to 63.3%; P=0.049) and the cure rates fell from 38.6% (26.2% to 52.7%) to 16.4 (7.7% to 31.3%; P=0.027).Conclusions All four currently recommended drugs show limitations in their efficacy profile. While only albendazole showed good efficacy against hookworm infection, all drugs had low efficacy against T trichiura The decrease in efficacy of albendazole against T trichiura over the past two decades is of concern. The findings indicate the need for strengthening efforts to develop new drug treatments, with a particular focus on drugs against T trichiura.
引用
- Moser W, Schindler C, Keiser J, et al. Efficacy of recommended drugs against soil transmitted helminths: systematic review and network meta-analysis. BMJ. 2017. PMID: 28947636. doi:10.1136/bmj.j4307
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。