文献速递流行病学与生物统计

用于分析元流行病学数据的标签不变模型

Label-invariant models for the analysis of meta-epidemiological data.
PubMed 文献 · Stat Med · 2017-09-19

针对元流行病学数据,Welton等人提出的模型强制特定特征研究的异质性至少与无该特征研究一样大,本研究提出对定义研究两分类的标签不变的替代模型。使用实施Cochrane偏倚风险工具的元分析集合,先考察小样本量(少于100名参与者)的影响,再考察多种方法学缺陷的影响。拟合Welton等人模型与提出的标签不变模型并比较结果,发现平均偏倚估计和试验间方差估计对模型选择不敏感。单变量模型结果显示,样本量少于100名参与者的试验异质性方差平均大88%;多变量模型中,序列生成不充分/不明确的研究异质性方差平均大25%,盲法不充分/不明确的研究平均大51%,分配隐藏不充分/不明确的研究平均低23%,但这些比值的95%区间非常宽。

要点

  • 提出的标签不变模型对定义研究两分类的标签不变,可用于分析元流行病学数据。
  • 样本量少于100名参与者的试验异质性方差平均大88%。
  • 多变量模型中,盲法不充分/不明确的研究异质性方差平均大51%,但95%区间非常宽。

核心结论

  • 提出的标签不变模型有助于研究特定研究特征导致的试验间异质性。

研究设计与样本

  • 方法学研究,使用实施Cochrane偏倚风险工具的元分析集合,拟合Welton等人模型与提出的标签不变模型进行比较。

主要发现

  • 平均偏倚估计和试验间方差估计对模型选择不敏感。
  • 单变量模型显示,样本量少于100名参与者的试验异质性方差平均大88%。
  • 多变量模型显示,序列生成不充分/不明确的研究异质性方差平均大25%,盲法不充分/不明确的研究平均大51%,分配隐藏不充分/不明确的研究平均低23%,但这些比值的95%区间非常宽。

局限性

  • 多变量模型中序列生成、盲法和分配隐藏的异质性方差比值的95%区间非常宽。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Rich meta-epidemiological data sets have been collected to explore associations between intervention effect estimates and study-level characteristics. Welton et al proposed models for the analysis of meta-epidemiological data, but these models are restrictive because they force heterogeneity among studies with a particular characteristic to be at least as large as that among studies without the characteristic. In this paper we present alternative models that are invariant to the labels defining the 2 categories of studies. To exemplify the methods, we use a collection of meta-analyses in which the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool has been implemented. We first investigate the influence of small trial sample sizes (less than 100 participants), before investigating the influence of multiple methodological flaws (inadequate or unclear sequence generation, allocation concealment, and blinding). We fit both the Welton et al model and our proposed label-invariant model and compare the results. Estimates of mean bias associated with the trial characteristics and of between-trial variances are not very sensitive to the choice of model. Results from fitting a univariable model show that heterogeneity variance is, on average, 88% greater among trials with less than 100 participants. On the basis of a multivariable model, heterogeneity variance is, on average, 25% greater among trials with inadequate/unclear sequence generation, 51% greater among trials with inadequate/unclear blinding, and 23% lower among trials with inadequate/unclear allocation concealment, although the 95% intervals for these ratios are very wide. Our proposed label-invariant models for meta-epidemiological data analysis facilitate investigations of between-study heterogeneity attributable to certain study characteristics.

来源:Stat Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Rhodes KM, Mawdsley D, Turner RM, et al. Label-invariant models for the analysis of meta-epidemiological data. Stat Med. 2017. PMID: 28929507. doi:10.1002/sim.7491

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。