印度北方邦一项随机对照试验中整合数据质量保证方案的实施与结果
在印度北方邦开展的BetterBirth匹配配对整群随机对照试验中,研究团队设计并实施了数据质量监测与改进系统(DQMIS),包含监测评估团队、数据质量保证方案、培训、标准操作规程和电子数据收集报告系统五个功能组件。该系统在所有数据收集活动中实现了98.33%的准确率,数据收集员在连续审计中准确率显著提高(p=0.0004)。
要点
- DQMIS整合审计、快速数据反馈和支持性监督,在资源有限地区大型随机对照试验中可行。
- 所有数据收集活动准确率达98.33%,数据收集员在连续审计中准确率显著提高(p=0.0004)。
- 尽管数据收集员从20名增至130名,DQMIS仍成功维持数据质量。
核心结论
- 在缺乏广泛传播的数据质量方法与标准的有限资源地区大型随机对照试验中,研究团队开发了整合审计、快速数据反馈和支持性监督的数据质量保证系统,确保了高质量数据,可作为未来卫生系统研究试验的模型。
研究设计与样本
- BetterBirth试验为匹配配对整群随机对照试验,在印度北方邦120个研究点观察超过6300次分娩并随访超过153000对母婴以评估健康结局。
- 研究设计并实施了数据质量监测与改进系统(DQMIS),包含监测评估团队、数据质量保证方案(含数据收集审计与目标、快速数据反馈、支持性监督)、培训、标准操作规程和电子数据收集报告系统五个功能组件。
主要发现
- DQMIS五个功能组件成功强化了数据可靠性、及时性、完整性、精确性和完整性。
- DQMIS使试验中所有数据收集活动的准确率达到98.33%。
- 所有数据收集活动在实施过程中准确率均有所改善。
- 数据收集员在连续审计中准确率显著提高(p=0.0004)。
- 尽管数据收集员从20名增至130名,DQMIS仍取得成功。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There are few published standards or methodological guidelines for integrating Data Quality Assurance (DQA) protocols into large-scale health systems research trials, especially in resource-limited settings. The BetterBirth Trial is a matched-pair, cluster-randomized controlled trial (RCT) of the BetterBirth Program, which seeks to improve quality of facility-based deliveries and reduce 7-day maternal and neonatal mortality and maternal morbidity in Uttar Pradesh, India. In the trial, over 6300 deliveries were observed and over 153,000 mother-baby pairs across 120 study sites were followed to assess health outcomes. We designed and implemented a robust and integrated DQA system to sustain high-quality data throughout the trial. METHODS: We designed the Data Quality Monitoring and Improvement System (DQMIS) to reinforce six dimensions of data quality: accuracy, reliability, timeliness, completeness, precision, and integrity. The DQMIS was comprised of five functional components: 1) a monitoring and evaluation team to support the system; 2) a DQA protocol, including data collection audits and targets, rapid data feedback, and supportive supervision; 3) training; 4) standard operating procedures for data collection; and 5) an electronic data collection and reporting system. Routine audits by supervisors included double data entry, simultaneous delivery observations, and review of recorded calls to patients. Data feedback reports identified errors automatically, facilitating supportive supervision through a continuous quality improvement model. RESULTS: The five functional components of the DQMIS successfully reinforced data reliability, timeliness, completeness, precision, and integrity. The DQMIS also resulted in 98.33% accuracy across all data collection activities in the trial. All data collection activities demonstrated improvement in accuracy throughout implementation. Data collectors demonstrated a statistically significant (p = 0.0004) increase in accuracy throughout consecutive audits. The DQMIS was successful, despite an increase from 20 to 130 data collectors. CONCLUSIONS: In the absence of widely disseminated data quality methods and standards for large RCT interventions in limited-resource settings, we developed an integrated DQA system, combining auditing, rapid data feedback, and supportive supervision, which ensured high-quality data and could serve as a model for future health systems research trials. Future efforts should focus on standardization of DQA processes for health systems research. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier, NCT02148952 . Registered on 13 February 2014.
引用
- Gass JD, Misra A, Yadav MNS, et al. Implementation and results of an integrated data quality assurance protocol in a randomized controlled trial in Uttar Pradesh, India. Trials. 2017. PMID: 28882167. doi:10.1186/s13063-017-2159-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。