医疗器械随机临床试验开展的具体障碍
本文通过系统性文献检索及欧洲临床研究基础设施网络(ECRIN)2013至2017年的内部沟通,识别出医疗器械随机临床试验的三大障碍:随机化(含评估时机、可接受性、盲法、对照选择和学习曲线)、结局指标确定困难、缺乏科学建议、法规与透明度;文章提出潜在解决方案并主张在评估医疗器械获益与危害时采用随机临床试验设计。
要点
- 医疗器械随机临床试验的障碍包括随机化相关的评估时机、可接受性、盲法、对照选择和学习曲线问题。
- 确定合适的结局指标存在困难。
- 缺乏科学建议、法规和透明度是另一主要障碍。
核心结论
- 本综述针对所识别的障碍提出潜在解决方案,并主张在评估医疗器械的获益与危害时应用随机临床试验设计。
研究设计与样本
- 系统性文献检索(未进行Meta分析)及欧洲临床研究基础设施网络(ECRIN)在ECRIN整合活动(ECRIN-IA)项目背景下于2013至2017年间面对面会议和电话会议中进行的内部沟通。
主要发现
- 除所有试验共有的障碍外,识别出医疗器械随机临床试验的三大障碍:随机化(包括评估时机、可接受性、盲法、对照组成员选择和学习曲线考量)、确定合适结局指标的困难、缺乏科学建议、法规和透明度。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Medical devices play an important role in the diagnosis, prevention, treatment and care of diseases. However, compared to pharmaceuticals, there is no rigorous formal regulation for demonstration of benefits and exclusion of harms to patients. The medical device industry argues that the classical evidence hierarchy cannot be applied for medical devices, as randomised clinical trials are impossible to perform. This article aims to identify the barriers for randomised clinical trials on medical devices. METHODS: Systematic literature searches without meta-analysis and internal European Clinical Research Infrastructure Network (ECRIN) communications taking place during face-to-face meetings and telephone conferences from 2013 to 2017 within the context of the ECRIN Integrating Activity (ECRIN-IA) project. RESULTS: In addition to the barriers that exist for all trials, we identified three major barriers for randomised clinical trials on medical devices, namely: (1) randomisation, including timing of assessment, acceptability, blinding, choice of the comparator group and considerations on the learning curve; (2) difficulties in determining appropriate outcomes; and (3) the lack of scientific advice, regulations and transparency. CONCLUSIONS: The present review offers potential solutions to break down the barriers identified, and argues for applying the randomised clinical trial design when assessing the benefits and harms of medical devices.
引用
- Neugebauer EAM, Rath A, Antoine SL, et al. Specific barriers to the conduct of randomised clinical trials on medical devices. Trials. 2017. PMID: 28903769. doi:10.1186/s13063-017-2168-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。