阶梯楔形设计:来自实验设计视角的洞见
本文从交叉试验与实验设计视角探讨阶梯楔形设计(SWD),证明线性混合效应模型中的治疗效应估计量可分解为传统行-列设计与省略行效应的「垂直分析」估计量的加权均值,并量化了相关参数误设导致的效率损失,还比较了多种处理的多处理扩展设计。
要点
- SWD治疗效应估计量可分解为行-列设计与垂直分析估计量的加权均值。
- 该分解精确表达了「水平」与「垂直」比较,并揭示分析如何校正时间与治疗的部分混杂。
- 误设混合模型相关参数会造成效率损失,垂直分析的最优扩展在实际组内依赖取值下效率极低。
核心结论
- 线性混合效应模型中的治疗效应估计量可分解为传统行-列设计估计量与省略行效应的垂直分析估计量的加权均值。
- 该分解精确表达了此前文献中无正式描述的「水平」与「垂直」比较。
- 误设混合效应模型中的相关参数会导致效率损失,且垂直分析的最优扩展在实际可能遇到的组内依赖取值下效率极低。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为方法学文章,从交叉试验与实验设计视角对阶梯楔形设计(SWD)进行理论分析。
- 分析对象为线性混合效应模型下的治疗效应估计量,并扩展至含多种处理的SWD变体。
主要发现
- 治疗效应估计量可分解为传统行-列设计估计量与垂直分析估计量的加权均值。
- 该分解显示分析有时以出人意料的方式校正时间与治疗效应间的部分混杂。
- 该方法可量化混合效应模型中相关参数误设造成的效率损失。
- 垂直分析的最优扩展在实际可能遇到的组内依赖取值下效率极低。
- 利用实验设计框架比较了近期描述的含多种处理的经典SWD扩展。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Stepped wedge designs (SWDs) have received considerable attention recently, as they are potentially a useful way to assess new treatments in areas such as health services implementation. Because allocation is usually by cluster, SWDs are often viewed as a form of cluster-randomized trial. However, since the treatment within a cluster changes during the course of the study, they can also be viewed as a form of crossover design. This article explores SWDs from the perspective of crossover trials and designed experiments more generally. We show that the treatment effect estimator in a linear mixed effects model can be decomposed into a weighted mean of the estimators obtained from (1) regarding an SWD as a conventional row-column design and (2) a so-called vertical analysis, which is a row-column design with row effects omitted. This provides a precise representation of "horizontal" and "vertical" comparisons, respectively, which to date have appeared without formal description in the literature. This decomposition displays a sometimes surprising way the analysis corrects for the partial confounding between time and treatment effects. The approach also permits the quantification of the loss of efficiency caused by mis-specifying the correlation parameter in the mixed-effects model. Optimal extensions of the vertical analysis are obtained, and these are shown to be highly inefficient for values of the within-cluster dependence that are likely to be encountered in practice. Some recently described extensions to the classic SWD incorporating multiple treatments are also compared using the experimental design framework.
引用
- Matthews JNS, Forbes AB. Stepped wedge designs: insights from a design of experiments perspective. Stat Med. 2017. PMID: 28786236. doi:10.1002/sim.7403
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。